I have to say, I stayed at the All Star Music Resort last year and I wasn't disappointed. I don't feel that there is anything more guady about the Pop Century Resort than the other All Stars. It takes up a new theme, one that has a lot of material to work with. I think it's a lot larger too. I agree with some of you who said that it will appeal to kids, and it will. Think how wonderful it would be to be a child and get to STAY in something like this. To most children it would probably be more exciting than staying at Grand Floridian.
My boyfriend, however, was slighty disappointed with the All Star. He had visited WDW before when he was younger, but never on property. His complaints had little to do with the resort, but more with the guests we had as neighbors for the week. Not all of the people, but most, I hate to admit.. were somewhat trashy staying at the resort. I guess thats what you have to deal with when you can't stay in a deluxe... but some of us don't have that kind of dough at this point in our lives and for my buck the All Stars are more than satisfactory. Although, on my other visits, I've stayed at Fort Wilderness Campground with my family, and would prefer that over staying in a value resort. These is just something about FW!