Official American Idol Season 4 Thread

[skiwee1]

But this leaves the question.... Who the HECK is voting for Scott!?!

Seems to be more people that voted for Nadia and Bo. Seriously just because a few on this board doesn't like him doesn't mean everybody doesn't either. He has a huge fan base. Everyone I know likes him the best out of all the singers. I only vote for Scott but realize he isn't going to be the Idol. I just want to see him get as far as he can.

 

[orangeblossom]

Thank God Bo was safe...My heart stopped.

 

[J.Cooper]

It breaks my heart to see Nadia leave tonight. I think she has more presence and star quality than anyone who's left...

She's gorgeous and fun to watch. She has potential to model, act or sing, and I'm hoping this will be a stepping stone to performing jobs for her.

I totally agree. Nadia has style and class! I hope someone signs her to there record label. I can also see her doing some modeling. She is a beautiful girl and definitely has the figure and pizazz. I wish her well. I did not like seeing her let go tonight. I think that darn Scott needs to go. He has no rhythm and he sings only ballards. Just stiff on stage. I hope he goes next week.

 

[Spinning]

Wow I was shocked. I really thought there was a chance Carrie was going to be in the bottom 3. But not Bo.
But I think he looked almost happy to be in the bottom 3 and it wouldn't have phased him if was voted off.
I really think he is going to have a wonderful career. But my only concern and this could be his too. He is true rocker. Will the rock fan base who don't watch AI be keen on him?

I think Constantine really isn't a big rocker. He may be in a band and may have the look but he really is more pop in MHO. I think he must be wonderful on stage. I can easily see him in Tommy or Hair.

 

[SPAM]

omg. i seriously had a heart attack. why the heck was bo in the bottom 3? no, for real. i dont understand. and why was scott safe. i hate scott. why cant he just leave. why do people keep voting for him. i am soo glad bo is safe. wheeww.

 

[damo]

That was too scary. Come on you guys, someone please vote for Bo for me!!!

 

[txaggie94gigem]

I had a feeling after that performance that Nadia might go but I thought for sure Scott would after that sub par performance and what he said to Simon....

please send him home......

 

[eeyore0062]

I was SO UNimpressed w/ Bo tonight. It is as though he knows he has it made, and could not care less. It shows in his performance. It SO irritates me, knowing how much this means for the rest of the contestants up there who are really going out of their way to give it their all.

I was hoping that Nadia would stay and Bo would be voted out. At this point, and with his attitude, he doesn't deserve to be there.

BTW, the bottom 3 didn't surprise me at all!

 

[Slacking]

The only people I know who actually voting for Scott are these people.


Can't believe though, that he actually has real fans.

 

[julia & nicks mom]

I was really put off by Bo's comments tonight - he acted like he didn't care if he won or lost - and I really think that is starting to show in his performances!

Simon was right - had Nadia given that performance last night she would still be in the competition!!!

 

[Nancy]

The only people I know who actually voting for Scott are these people.


Can't believe though, that he actually has real fans.

I have liked Scott's voice from day 1. His attitude has bothered me..but not his voice. But he does do the same type of music every week. The only performance that wasn't good was last weeks musical selection. He statrted out bad last night but did very well after a shaky start. AS for the ballads. Anwar has only sung ballads...has anyone seen him sing a fast one? Anthony's fastest song was the latin number he did way back. Only the girls have shown versitality. The guys all do the same...Bo..rocks, Anthony and Anwar do ballads, Constantine does theatrics, no matter what he sings...it all sounds theatrical and overdone.

 

[orangeblossom]

The fact that Bo doesn't care and knows that he'll be okay without this is what I like best about him.

 

[Nancy]

The fact that Bo doesn't care and knows that he'll be okay without this is what I like best about him.

Me too...it's a very down to earth and "not into himself" attitude. He knows he's got a deal when this over, no matter what!

 

[Cindy B]

The fact that Bo doesn't care and knows that he'll be okay without this is what I like best about him.

I agree. I didn't find it arrogant at all, just very direct. I do beleive there is a difference between arrogance and directness.

 

[macraven]

like the group said tonight, all dread wednesdays.........


what will be next weeks theme............if you hear what it is , please post it for us on this thread. we love rumors here !!


already in the mood and looking forward to next tuesday.....

 

[SPAM]

i didnt find what bo said arrogant at all. at all. he meant that if he doesnt win he'll still be happy doing what hes doing. singing. i love the carefree attitude he has and im definetely going to vote for him next week. did anyone try to vote alot last night, like me, but could never get through?

 

[Nancy]

This morning my kids started asking me if I "heard" any rumours yet. I love the rumours because then I know more then the girls do for a change!

 

[eeyore0062]

I agree. I didn't find it arrogant at all, just very direct. I do beleive there is a difference between arrogance and directness.

I didn't think Bo came across as arrogant, just that he didn't give a hoot. That bothers me because the others are up there really giving their all, and he is just phoning in his performances. I can't stand that kind of attitude. He is right though, he will be fine with or without the Idol title, so why give it to him? There are others who do deserve it and are really doing everything they can to shine. It is one of those people who deserve the title.

 

[orangeblossom]

I really don't think he said he doesn't give a hoot...I think he said that it's fun for him and while he'd like to do well, he's not stressing over it....two totally different things.
Why vote for him? Because I honestly think he has the look, voice, and personality that I'd like an American Idol to have. He's the type I would want my children to look up to if I had children.

 

[Southern4sure]

Who are the tune deaf people voting to keep Scott on AI? He is not the best, he is not consistant, He is not a AI roll model and he is the one who is arrogant!

Bo was being Bo. He was not arrogant and he was not going to burst into tears if he went home. He is just as happy and content singing in his band as he would be if he won. That is what is real. Bo is consistant in his singing and his attitude has not wavered from day one. Bo is happy with himself and what he has accomplished and is self confident. Bo is the only one who does not look like he is about to cry on the dreaded Wendsdays.

Southern4sure