Not the best Le Cellier experience

Senor_Jorge

Earning My Ears
Joined
Jun 29, 2010
Messages
58
Having dined at Le Cellier two years ago we were looking forward to it, even knowing that it had increased to 2 DDP.

We had a reservation for 7:15 PM, got there around 6A:45 PM and checked in at the podium and went inside to take some available seats to wait. While picking up some menus I saw our reservation print and be placed to the side, returned to my seat and my wife and I looked at the menu. The room filled and emptied.

My wife noticed the staff becoming uncomfortable, but I assumed they were running a bit behind. She was right. For those that have been there, we were seated on the bench that has a 90 degree view of the front desk. Eventually a host/server asked if anyone had a reservation that had not been seated. We told him that we had a reservation for 7:15. At that point it was 7:35.

He checked the system, and then moved some items that had been placed over our reservation ticket that had printed out while I picked up the menus. My wife asked if they were running late, and his response was that our ticket had just been printed.

I understand that mistakes happen, but owning my own business and dealing with clients I don't have a lot of understanding for a blatant lie. Tell me you made a mistake and apologize. That's sufficient.

As a result, our meal started on a bad note but I had hope since the filet that I had two years previously was full of flavor and VERY well cooked. That didn't work out either.

Those that have dined at Le Cellier may be familiar with some of the tables for two along the walls, and understand that they are fairly close together. We ended up next to one or two current or former employees. Apparently they had been there for a while, and left shortly before our meal ended. That was after we placed our dessert order, and before it arrived. They were fine, as was there behavior...with the exception of other employees coming by to chat and in some cases trying to slide between the 18 inches that separated our tables. I'm not sure who 'Emily' is, but the young lady seated next to use seemed inclined to stay until asked to leave. If management allows it, I'm in no position to point a finger at an employee.

My ribeye was above average, my wife's filet was overcooked but she hadn't sliced into the center to check it when our server asked if everything came out as we'd ordered it. On that note I'd like to thanks Colin from Ontario. His service was excellent, and was the best part of our dining experience.

I made a decision not to deal with either situation while trying to enjoy our meal, because I didn't feel that it would end well for anyone. Our reservations were on the 14th of December and we returned home on the 19th. Email was sent to Disney on the 20th.

I didn't expect any compensation, nor did I ask for any. I did expect someone to acknowledge the issue. That has yet to happen. I understand that it's the busiest time of the year, but for that moment it was the most important time of our vacation.

Le Cellier has gone from a destination restaurant while at Disney, to a place that I will never dine again.
 
On our last trip to Le Cellier (it was still one credit) we were also underwhelmed. We ordered the prime rib which had previously been great. Mine was really dry (ordered medium, but came out medium well). I asked for au jus and was told they only have au jus at lunchtime, but I could have horseradish--yeah, that's just the thing for dry meat!
My son had a new york strip and I was wishing I'd ordered that.
Way overrated, and in no way worth 2 TS credits.
Daisyx3
 
on our trip this year we had an amazingly good meal however for a signature restaurant you don't get the roomy seating you would expect and I can understand people getting cross with that. Also if the food isn't up to par then for the cost that needs remedying. Poor service is unforgiveable anywhere. We all make errors but I'm with the op admit it apologise and move on.
 
i must agree with chocolateMinnie. we went a few years ago and couldn't get over how cranped it was. the restaurant in Mexico is the same.
 

I've heard numerous people lately mention a very below expectation meal at Le Cellier! DH and I dined there for lunch the beginning of Dec and I have to agree! It wasn't what I remembered or expected! As DH and I were doing the Candlelight Processional package the meal was 2 credits. It definitely wasn't worth 2 credits a piece! I'm glad DDP was free because I would have been a little disappointed and annoyed to spend 2 credits on it!
 
funny, we had the exact opposite experience. We've dined there before and it has been hit or miss.
We decided to give it another shot. Yes, it is still crapped, but our meals were quite good. We each had the filet and they were prepared exactly to our request.
 
We ate at Le Cellier for the first time on Dec 4th and really enjoyed our meal. Our food (we both had the filet) was done just right and we had great service. (We also had Colin as our server!) We were nervous about eating there after reading so many negative reviews but were pleased with the meal. We will definitely go back on our next trip. Sorry to hear you didn't enjoy your meal and had such a bad experience.
 
We ate at Le Cellier for the first time on Dec 4th and really enjoyed our meal. Our food (we both had the filet) was done just right and we had great service. (We also had Colin as our server!) We were nervous about eating there after reading so many negative reviews but were pleased with the meal. We will definitely go back on our next trip. Sorry to hear you didn't enjoy your meal and had such a bad experience.


It happens, and I'm glad that you enjoyed yours! I'm disappointed that there has been no response to my email, and honestly a bit surprised. My experience has been that Disney has always been very responsive in the past. My mistake, for not addressing the situation at the time it occurred.

I'll add that I miss the Tomatoe Stack, but the new version using heirloom tomatoes is very good. In the future, if asked, I'll have no problem telling anyone that asks that they can probably get a very good meal there. I'll also share our experience. I wouldn't discourage anyone from dining there again, but I doubt we will ever do that in the future.

My wife and I dined at The Yachtsman Steakhouse a couple of nights later, and it is a very suitable replacement. The porterhouse and ribeye that we ordered were excellent, as were the sides and service, and being on the dining plan it was still 2 points each. Give it some thought on your next visit, if you have a few extra points burning a hole in your pocket.
 
We ate there two years ago and LOVED it and then went again last year and it was not as good. I'd try it again though...it might have just been the day or the order or whatever. I usually give things a few chances before I really rule them out for good.
 
OP- the same thing happened to our ticket at lunch time back in October. We didn't arrive as early as you did, but it wasn't over-packed, either. We arrived probably 5-10 minutes early, sat there as we watched others seated, then noticed people that arrived after us were being seated. I asked the hostess about it and they couldn't figure out what was going on. Apparently since our ticket was printed we weren't showing up on their main computer screen. The "floor manager" (not sure what to call that position) came to the front to find out what was going on because she saw our table sitting there empty for so long. About that time they found it under some other items and promptly seated us.

Our food was pretty good, the other time we were there my wife had the coffee rubbed KC strip but it is no longer on the menu. That was disappointing because it had a really good flavor. Our server was ok at best, she took a little long at times to fill drinks, bring our check, etc. I always finish eating before my family but I ended up waiting for the check by myself about 10 minutes while my wife took our kids to the next attraction. She also acted like she could care less if we were there or not. No big deal.

Pixie Chick- the place is crapped? Ummm..not sure I want to eat there. Ha ha!
 
I was very surprised to get a call this morning, as well as on a Saturday, from someone at Disney!

They apologized for the delay in contacting me, as well as for the original experience we had. They asked all of the right questions, and said all of the right things.

The easy thing to do would have been to just let it go after 6 months. The effort is appreciated! Good business too. I ended up looking at a short visit in September to surprise my wife for our anniversary. I hope she doesn't read this forum!
 
My last visit to LeCellier was so horrifically bad that I vowed never to return. Like you, I arrived early only to STAND (all the seats were taken) for 45 minutes waiting. My wife and I were then seated at a table for two slid between two tables of 4 in an alcove. I spent the whole meal staring at the rear end of servers serving either side, or the people sliding in and out around the 18 inches between the tables, and having the table be jostled by them, or being bumped into by them. When we asked to move to another table after the salad course, the man with the tablet (who assigns tables) hautilly told us that those tables "were no better" and refused to move us. Service was glacially slow. My medium steak came out well done and not particularly hot. My wife's medium steak was rare. We sent both back. The replacements were both well done. Mine was obviously the same steak stuck under a heat lamp. How it was supposed to reverse the cooking process, I don't know. Dessert was the best part of the meal because we got to leave afterward. Never, ever again will we be going there.
 







New Posts









Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top