Okay a newbie and I got to her first. Well second only cause I don't type as fast as Dom.
Hi Michelle
Yes the CM's will take your pin as long as it's a Disney pin, old, new from Disney Japan California Cruise line, whatever as long as its a Disney pin they take it. The exception to the rule is they sell these rubber pins or name pins those are not for trade. The rule applies that as long as they do not already have that pin on their lanyard they will trade.
If you come to Florida you will see that almost every lanyard has a default dancing 2000 pin on each and every lanyard, Disney did this because a local discount house was selling those pins for .99 cents. Somebody I would say several people bought hundreds of these pins and was trading those for lanyard pins, then selling them on ebay. So you see by putting one on each lanyard they cant accept that pin for trade anymore.
I have never been on a cruise, but the lanyard rules should apply, the only time I have been told different was at a
Disney Store, they told me those were for show only, and only certain stores would be doing the lanyards for trade. Also during special events they bring out prototype pins on lanyards that are not for trade.
Yes cruise line pins are more desirable, because not everybody gets to go on the cruise, and they only sell them onboard ship. For a small time there they sold them at one of the resorts but they were pulled once the word got out.
There are two publications out there that I know of that talk about pins but the names escape me I'm sure others out there know which ones I'm talking about. One has information on pins the other has actual pin values.
The best way I learned was to do research on Pinpics.com they have the best collection of pin information, or go to Ebay and see what they are selling for. You would be surprised what people will pay for a pin. Example go to Ebay do a search for Mickey for President Pin.
Now for the fun stuff if you ever get to Florida, I would be honored to take you under the wings of the Contemporary Collecting Contingency. We have a meet every Friday night, and we can take you around and show you the ins and out of trading
you are guaranteed a great time but be prepared to laugh a lot.