I've talked about the reindeer being gone from the Round-Up and what I think about the idea of the parade, snow and fireworks becoming part of a holiday party in the Christmas Superthread, in my TR thread and elsewhere (way before this Lutz piece came out), so I don't want to repeat myself too much.
But I will add that I have noticed that it is very interesting to observe what the Disney folks say and do
not say in their Blogs or news items. You can kind of read between the lines and figure out which things are not coming back.
Under the recent Disney Parks Blog about the holiday season dates (which we all already knew months ago) and the new highlights vs. the "returning favorites," a reader posted a reply in the Comments section and asked Erin Glover (the author of that Blog) about the reindeer returning. Erin totally ignored that reindeer question, but answered another question about WoC right near it. It was clear to me at that moment that the reindeer would not be coming back to the Round-Up this year.
Also, another interesting thing to note is that I submitted a question/comment/reply to that same Blog, and I mentioned that I hoped the themed New Orleans Square decorations and themed Toontown decorations were among the "Returning Favorites," as Erin did not mention them in her blog.
And guess what? Not only did my question about NOS and TT never get answered, but my comment/question was never even posted...while many other comments that came in after mine were posted. I'm not sure if that means anything, but as I said, it's interesting to note what is said and what is not said...
In any case, my feeling is that, while I've expected a Christmas party for years, to me - because I've got the Halloween Superthread and the Christmas Superthread and I pay a
lot of attention to what exactly is added into and what is taken away from each season (other folks may not obsessively pay as much attention to that stuff as I do!

) - it seems like Disney is removing things from both Halloween and the holidays, little by little, while continuing to hike up the prices for everything.
If the party happens in the exact way Al Lutz is saying it will next year, and all of the seasonal price hikes go into effect at the same time, it will just seem like Disney is trying to do too much, too soon...all at one time. Taking the
longstanding holiday parade, snow and fireworks out of the regular seasonal entertainment will be a controversial and risky move. They will get a lot of backlash from longtime holiday visitors, I'm sure.
I think TDA has a hard time grasping the fact that DLR is never going to be WDW - logistically, it is just not possible, and the addition of Cars Land is not going to suddenly make DLR into WDW. And DLR shouldn't be WDW - they
should be different! But they are sure going to treat DLR like it's WDW until they have people believing that the resorts are equal.
But hey, the good news is that Downtown Disney is getting an ice rink and small Christmas "village" this year. Take away the reindeer; add in a rink!