We have made about 10 trips to Disney over the years, we started off-site and had a few really negative experiences with hotels not being anything like they were advertised. About 3 years ago we discovered POFQ and we were hooked for onsite-but mostly this hotel. We always rent a car so transportation is no big draw for us. About 18 mo ago we stayed offsite for a weekend before a cruise and really enjoyed ourselves, the price was great, the breakfast incl. was a big plus and it was about 5 min to disney. Since then we have done both including a delux stay last October, we loved the monorail access but boy the cost was huge. We were big users of early entry and were VERY disapointed in October for it to be dropped the very day we arived. the character caravan sucks, we see plenty of mickey and friends in the parks to satisify us. They closed our fav. hotel and shut down the boat to DD.
I started checking out the offsite board to plan our Sept. trip and found out about the New Country Inn and Suites, $54 a night, breakfast and only 5-10 min to disney. You can't do better than a brand new hotel.
We will find plenty of magic in the parks to suite us, we will have extra money to enjoy some nice meals in the parks and return to a comfortable hotel.
We will stay on-site again in the future but our September trip will be off-site and we will have a blast.