While we have stayed at both, we prefer Riverside. While my daughter likes the mansions better with their manicured lawns, etc. I prefer the bayou rooms, I like their less structured landscaping, etc. I also prefer to use the quiet pools more than the bigger themed ones. If you like the themed pools, the one at French Quarter is awesome. Any way you choose, you can't lose. Have fun and enjoy!
Smiles,
Diane =0)