Navy Seal, Matthew McCabe Acquitted of all charges.

DawnCt1

<font color=red>I had to wonder what "holiday" he
Joined
May 17, 2004
Messages
30,045
Justice has finally prevailed. All three Navy Seals have now been acquitted of assaulting the Iraqi terrorist who probably bit his own lip. Its a shame that they had to stand trial in the first place.

http://www.foxnews.com/us/2010/05/06/navy-seal-guilty-assaulting-suspected-terrorist/

Updated May 06, 2010
Navy SEAL Found Not guilty of Assaulting a Suspected Terrorist

FOXNews.com

Military jury found a Navy SEAL not guilty on charges of punching a suspected Iraqi terrorist.



Virginia military jury found a Navy SEAL not guilty on charges of punching a suspected Iraqi terrorist.

Matthew McCabe, a Special Operations Petty Officer Second Class (SO-2), was facing three charges: dereliction of performance of duty for willfully failing to safeguard a detainee, making a false official statement, and assault.
 
Justice has finally prevailed. All three Navy Seals have now been acquitted of assaulting the Iraqi terrorist who probably bit his own lip. Its a shame that they had to stand trial in the first place.

That's the truth!
 
Justice has finally prevailed. All three Navy Seals have now been acquitted of assaulting the Iraqi terrorist who probably bit his own lip. Its a shame that they had to stand trial in the first place.

Great news, thanks for posting this.
 
Just like in any other job, military personnel need to be held accountable when things aren't done according to rules and regulations.

People who are in the military don't get a free pass when it comes to international rules of warfare.
 
Well, I wouldn't put it past him for punching the guy, but he was acquitted so he can move on now.
 
Just like in any other job, military personnel need to be held accountable when things aren't done according to rules and regulations.

People who are in the military don't get a free pass when it comes to international rules of warfare.

These SEALS captured the lowest scum of the earth at great personal risk to themselves. Ahmed Hashim Abed, was on the most wanted list after torturing and killing Blackwater guards, former US soldiers themselves, and hanging their bodies from a bridge. He did what all Al Qaeda terrorists are trained to do, "claim abuse". Instead of believing our soldiers, those in charge believed the scumbag. That was the thanks they got for doing what had alluded soldiers for more than two years. Now lets hope that we hold the scumbags we capture to the same "rules", all off which were followed BTW, that we hold our own brave troops to.
 
Well, I wouldn't put it past him for punching the guy, but he was acquitted so he can move on now.

Why? Because the scum bag deserved it? I am puzzled by your BUT. Are you implying that he shouldn't have been acquitted or am I reading you wrong?
 
These SEALS captured the lowest scum of the earth at great personal risk to themselves. Ahmed Hashim Abed, was on the most wanted list after torturing and killing Blackwater guards, former US soldiers themselves, and hanging their bodies from a bridge. He did what all Al Qaeda terrorists are trained to do, "claim abuse". Instead of believing our soldiers, those in charge believed the scumbag. That was the thanks they got for doing what had alluded soldiers for more than two years. Now lets hope that we hold the scumbags we capture to the same "rules", all off which were followed BTW, that we hold our own brave troops to.

For me, it falls under the whole "power because you can"...or does your outrage about abuses of power only apply to police officers?

This man doesn't get a pass just because he's military.

The military has rules and regulations to follow ~ if they aren't followed, there are consequences.
 
For me, it falls under the whole "power because you can"...or does your outrage about abuses of power only apply to police officers?

This man doesn't get a pass just because he's military.

The military has rules and regulations to follow ~ if they aren't followed, there are consequences.

There was absolutely no evidence that he was punched. The oral surgeon who examined the vermin said that the injury appeared to be self inflicted. They followed the rules. I will save my outrage for American citizens and not murderous terrorists who are well schooled in the AQ playbook.
 
There was absolutely no evidence that he was punched. The oral surgeon who examined the vermin said that the injury appeared to be self inflicted. They followed the rules. I will save my outrage for American citizens and not murderous terrorists who are well schooled in the AQ playbook.

I never said he was guilty. :) I was talking about military personnel in general. They have rules, regulations and laws to follow just like civilians.

When those rules, regulations and laws are not followed per a military court, soldiers are brought up on charges ~ just the way it should be.
 
I never said he was guilty. :) I was talking about military personnel in general. They have rules, regulations and laws to follow just like civilians.

When those rules, regulations and laws are not followed per a military court, soldiers are brought up on charges ~ just the way it should be.

Again, there was no evidence that any rules were broken and someone should have ruled on the evidence or lack of evidence and dismissed the accusations and the charges before staging this "show trial" for the benefit of our enemies. They won't like us more. They will see that we are weak. By throwing our brave SEALS under the bus, we look weak.
 
Again, there was no evidence that any rules were broken and someone should have ruled on the evidence or lack of evidence and dismissed the accusations and the charges before staging this "show trial" for the benefit of our enemies. They won't like us more. They will see that we are weak. By throwing our brave SEALS under the bus, we look weak.

The charges were brought up and tried in a military court, by Major General Charles Cleveland. It wasn't done in the civilian court system, so no one was thrown "under the bus". :rolleyes:

"Despite the opinions of some who preferred that these charges not proceed, I allowed these charges to go forward because I truly believe that the best process known for uncovering the truth, when the facts are contested, is that process which is found in our adversarial justice system," Cleveland said in a statement after McCabe's acquittal.
 
Why? Because the scum bag deserved it? I am puzzled by your BUT. Are you implying that he shouldn't have been acquitted or am I reading you wrong?

So you agree he did it? I'm not saying he shouldn't have been acquitted, I'm just saying I think he punched him, that's all.
 
So you agree he did it? I'm not saying he shouldn't have been acquitted, I'm just saying I think he punched him, that's all.

No, you seem to be saying that "he did it". He obviously didn't do it. He said he didn't do it and he was acquitted.
 
Honestly.....who cares if he puched this TERRORIST. For what he did (the TERRORIST), he should have been executed on sight!!! THis is a war people, we need to stop handcuffing what our guys (the good guys) can do. IF you are TRYING to kill us, a little punch to the mouth should be the least of your problems.We need to take the gloves off and win this thing any way we can. Mathew McCabe, you have my complete respect and thanks for your service to our once great, and hopefully soon to be again, great country!!!:thumbsup2
 
I hope he did punch the terrorist, and I'm thrilled he was acquitted!:thumbsup2
 
Honestly.....who cares if he puched this TERRORIST. For what he did (the TERRORIST), he should have been executed on sight!!! THis is a war people, we need to stop handcuffing what our guys (the good guys) can do. IF you are TRYING to kill us, a little punch to the mouth should be the least of your problems.We need to take the gloves off and win this thing any way we can. Mathew McCabe, you have my complete respect and thanks for your service to our once great, and hopefully soon to be again, great country!!!:thumbsup2

I hope he did punch the terrorist, and I'm thrilled he was acquitted!:thumbsup2

If I had the opportunity I would have been thrilled to punch the terrorist, but since Matthew McCabe said that he didn't, I will take his word for it. I too am thrilled. It should never have gone to trial.
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom