There is another thread - Narcoosee's, the good the bad and the ugly with lots of opinions.
http://www.disboards.com/showthread.php?t=1731782
Here is my post from that thread...
On the
DDP, I would do Narcoosee's again. The food was good, the atmosphere is very nice.
I think the bad reviews stem from the build up of "The best seafood ever" that seem to pop up every now and then.
I'll be honest, I love seafood and I have been to many seafood places. The food really reminded me of Red Lobster. The atmosphere is more romantic, and the view is beautiful. The service was very nice, but the food itself is very normal safe seafood. The sides also, very safe and very normal. Nothing special or extraordinary.
I describe Narcoosee's as Red Lobster with a much better view and much nicer atmosphere. It's also much more expensive than Red Lobster, so it's a perfect DDP meal.
Go and enjoy your anniversary there, I think bad reviews are people who aren't happy with the safe/normal seafood.