Actually we are in the same situation. I have an ADR at Yachtsman (also at Concourse and Le Cellier) so I was thinking of changing our "special Anniversary dinner" to Narcoossee's. Three steakhouses in 5 nights is a little much - even for us as we're huge steak fans! I think that the Narcoossee's menu seems interesting and we're hoping to be able to watch the fireworks from there. Plus we're staying at VWL so it should be a bit closer. Have you decided to eat at Narcoossee's?
After I asked this question I searched around on some other menus and the Narcoossee's menu on the dis shows the the surf and turf is served with some kind of potato - no mention of spoon bread!
When are you going to WDW? Our dates are 10/14-20. Enjoy your trip!
On a personal note, I just realized where you are from! I grew up in So. Central Pa - near Carlisle - and lived in Philly before my DH dragged me to VA. Plus I was (and still am) a huge PSU fan. Since we live in Blacksburg and my DH is a VT alumni, he has switched me over to the dark side (Virginia Tech). I have two uncles who are PSU alums and bleed blue and white. I also have a sister at Pitt!