We had a similar experience in December. When we got to the podium, they said we did not have a reservation. When I game them my reservation number, they were able to pull it up. BUT, they said it was for an hour after I had originally made the reservation!!! I couldn't argue with them and didn't know how to prove that I had not made a reservation at 8:25 with boys that usually go to bed at 8. They would not even take our name and told me to come back at 8. We were finally seated at 9 and my youngest son slept through the entire meal. I wasn't charged for my son's meal (we were on the dining plan, so an extra credit didn't really do anything for us). I haven't complained because we had much worse happen on the trip- $250 stolen from my bag at bell services- and I didn't want to dilute the worst issue by complaining too much.