I just bought a brand new Nissan Pathfinder and traded in my Nissan Sentra for $1,300 but the blue book value was $2,300. (Yes I am a huge Nissan fan) That would have been in your range, easily. I would go with a private party. I was going to try and sell my car, then realized I didn't want to go through the hassel and would take the lower price. Keep looking in the papers and don't settle, be patient and the perfect car will come to you.