My advice on picking restaurants for your WDW trip

KellyHonos

DisneyDivaxo
Joined
Feb 27, 2018
Messages
484
Hey y'all! Right now I'm in the middle of planning a trip to WDW, and as you all know, part of the fun is making your dining reservations! As I was doing this, I realized that I had a method to my madness, and I thought I may share some of my advice, since maybe some people struggle with picking, get overwhelmed with options and may be visiting for the first time!

First, I'd like to say that this is my sixth trip to WDW, so I would not consider myself an expert by any stretch, but I'm moderately informed and aware of the restaurant options. I also keep up with the dining reviews the DIS Unplugged posts as well as other Disney-focused youtube channels. With all of that being said, take this as suggestions and not rules of thumb. Everyone has different dietary restrictions, tastes, budgets, etc. I'm just simply sharing some tips and tricks I use when it comes to picking out restaurants.

1. Look at your options. This may sound self-explanatory, but seriously, look. When I went back in 2013, I hadn't been since 2007 as a teen. In that time difference, so much changed and I didn't even know. I called in 2013 to make our dining reservations and I simply asked the customer service rep to suggest me a couple good restaurants in each park and reserve the one that had a more convenient time for me and my family...I had NO clue I could go on line and look at the vast variety of restaurants they had to offer in addition to photos and menus! Even though it can be time consuming and require some attention, you really give yourself the power to pick the very best options for you and your family.

2. You simply cannot do it all in your short stay--let go. There may be 15 restaurants you want to try but you only have 5 TS credits. JUST PICK 5 and let it go. So often we hear about people beating themselves up over not doing that and not doing this, but lets be realistic--you can't do it all, so do what you can. Once you relieve yourself of the FOMO (fear of missing out) pressure, you will be more relaxed and not have so much anxiety over feeling like you missed an opportunity or you picked the wrong place.

3. Compromise. Unless you are riding solo on your WDW trip, (which happens often and sounds amazing), there will be people in your party you most likely have to compromise with. I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but you can't pick all your favorite restaurants and not allow anyone else to pick things out. I think coming to an agreement with your family/friends is the best way to approach this. You can either only dine at places that sound equally good to all or a majority of you, OR you can split the days that you're staying and say that so and so can pick dinner these days, and so and so can pick dinner these days. Don't complicate it, just compromise. More than likely, there will be something on the menu for you, even if you didn't fancy the menu.

4. Alternate. I think one of the biggest mistakes I have made in previous visits is that since I'm a creature of habit, I like to revisit restaurants I've been to before that weren't worthy of the second or third visit. Maybe it's the nostalgia-freak in me, or the fact that I don't like making decisions, but either way, I've gone back to restaurants that weren't necessarily worth the visit back. I think looking back on previous trips, and really asking yourself if that meal was top-notch or just okay. There are plenty of opportunities to get top-notch meals with amazing scenery (and lets be real, you're paying a hefty price, so it might as well be top-notch if you can help it), so why settle for "eh" ones? I would suggest keeping 2-3 restaurants you really enjoyed from your previous visit(s), and then trying new things for the rest. The reason I suggest this is because there is so much to see in Disney, that you will never see it all in one visit. Give yourself the chance to see as much as possible and try new things! You may even find your new favorite!

5. Listen to reviews, but take them with a grain of salt. Restaurant reviews are very helpful for many reasons. It allows you to see people's honest reactions to the food, scenery, service, overall atmosphere, drink options, etc. This is really useful when it comes to making decisions on where to eat...BUT keep in mind that a meat eater will not have the most outstanding impression of a vegan restaurant and a vegan will not have the most outstanding review of a steakhouse. I say this because sometimes people go into restaurants to review menus that they themselves wouldn't be drawn to in the first place. If you're not a seafood person, you're most likely not going to enjoy a lobster dinner. If a menu looks compelling to you, and you watched a review on it that wasn't great, I say give it a try. If there are 3-4 bad reviews, that may be different. But if one bad review is making you question going somewhere, just go and form your own opinion. YOU may end up liking it!

6. It's JUST food. We put a lot of pressure on ourselves to have the most amazing experience, but in reality, we shouldn't take it so seriously. It's really just food. If you have an isolated incident that was underwhelming, remind yourself that you server is a human being with feelings, a personal life, a family and their own stresses. Just because you're at WDW doesn't mean you get to take your disappointment out onto people in forms of aggression and cussing. If you don't enjoy your meal, express that to your server. If problems continue to arise during your visit at any given restaurant, kindly ask for the manager. Then, if that doesn't put you at ease, ask for a contact higher up in management. If it's a health code violation or unprofessional/inappropriate behavior from a cast member, absolutely report it. Otherwise, LET IT GO. You're in WDW to have fun and escape your real life issues. Be kind, be patient, it's just food.

I hope some of these tips help you narrow down your restaurant choices when dining at WDW! If anyone has others, feel free to share!
 
Last edited:
Good advice. I'll add one more based on 8 trips as a family of 4. Pick a restaurant based on location. We always get park hoppers, but we eat lunch / dinner in the park we are visiting. Similar to that, we only book resort dining if we are staying at that resort. We don't have a car, and the kids have been too young for cabs to work, until recently.

This advice is based on doing the opposite a couple of time and paying the price (long travel, crabby family).
 
After six trips what are your fav places ?

-My favorite character dining experience is definitly Tusker House. Crystal Palace and Chef Mickeys are just okay.
-Favorite immersive restaurant is Be Our Guest. IMO, the food was good and we sat in the room with the wilting rose and the beast picture, so we really enjoyed ourselves there. It really feels like you're int the castle.
-Favorite restaurant in Worlds Show case was Nine Dragons.
-Mama Melrose is good in Hollywood studios. If you're intersted, you can get a Fantatsmic package.
 

Im at about 25 trips! My advise is location, location, location!

Pick your daily parks first, then plan dining on where you will be. Traveling around the bubble just for a meal is a huge waste of time.
Decide your budget. Depending on if youre on the dining package or paying OOP, you will know better what kinds of meals your want for breakfast, lunch or dinner
Remember Disney portions are HUGE,,,even for the hungriest of eaters. 2 meals a day is plenty. If youre a little hungry in between grab a snack.
Go to allears dot net, then click on Dining. All menus are there with pricing, broken down by park, resort table service, quick service....decide your location first, then the type of meal you want before looking at this website. If you go into it not knowing these 2 things, you will get overwhelmed.

You can read all the reviews you want, but remember EVERYONE has different tastes. I can tell you San Angel Inn is the best, but if your favorite is pasta, youre not going to love it there. I have heard rave reviews about school bread in Norway, but I hate coconut and thought it was disgusting. Only the person actually eating the meal can decide which they think it best.
 
Great advice in general!
5 of us are going on our next trip which is currently for 6 nights. I'm allowing each guest to pick one dinner venue (our main meal of the day) out of the list of signatures and 2 credit dinner shows. Since I know 'Ohana's and HDDR are wanted by at least 3 of the guests I've already booked them and that's out of my way.

As for the OP's reason number 5 I disagree. It's not just food....it's an experience in and of itself and adds to the overall reason for choosing Disney for my way of thinking. I need ambiance, good food and service to fulfill my wants and get value for funds spent.

As for reviews..I read them carefully and at various internet sites to get a better idea as to what to expect. Menu reading tells me a lot as well.
 
Good advice. I'll add one more based on 8 trips as a family of 4. Pick a restaurant based on location. We always get park hoppers, but we eat lunch / dinner in the park we are visiting. Similar to that, we only book resort dining if we are staying at that resort. We don't have a car, and the kids have been too young for cabs to work, until recently.

This advice is based on doing the opposite a couple of time and paying the price (long travel, crabby family).

Location is key! I have seen so many posts that ask for tips on how to get to Restaurant A from Park Z and then be at Park X an hour and ten minutes later to make a FP that was booked, YIKES!

WE look at our park days, and when we plan to be in the parks, and then book our meals. We often add resort dining to our list, however because we tend to go back to our resort at some point before dinner, it is not inconvenient for us.
 
Im at about 25 trips! My advise is location, location, location!

Pick your daily parks first, then plan dining on where you will be. Traveling around the bubble just for a meal is a huge waste of time.
Decide your budget. Depending on if youre on the dining package or paying OOP, you will know better what kinds of meals your want for breakfast, lunch or dinner
Remember Disney portions are HUGE,,,even for the hungriest of eaters. 2 meals a day is plenty. If youre a little hungry in between grab a snack.
Go to allears dot net, then click on Dining. All menus are there with pricing, broken down by park, resort table service, quick service....decide your location first, then the type of meal you want before looking at this website. If you go into it not knowing these 2 things, you will get overwhelmed.

You can read all the reviews you want, but remember EVERYONE has different tastes. I can tell you San Angel Inn is the best, but if your favorite is pasta, youre not going to love it there. I have heard rave reviews about school bread in Norway, but I hate coconut and thought it was disgusting. Only the person actually eating the meal can decide which they think it best.


That school bread was SICK. Me and my sister ordered it and we were both really disappointed
 
Great advice in general!
5 of us are going on our next trip which is currently for 6 nights. I'm allowing each guest to pick one dinner venue (our main meal of the day) out of the list of signatures and 2 credit dinner shows. Since I know 'Ohana's and HDDR are wanted by at least 3 of the guests I've already booked them and that's out of my way.

As for the OP's reason number 5 I disagree. It's not just food....it's an experience in and of itself and adds to the overall reason for choosing Disney for my way of thinking. I need ambiance, good food and service to fulfill my wants and get value for funds spent.

As for reviews..I read them carefully and at various internet sites to get a better idea as to what to expect. Menu reading tells me a lot as well.


Understandable you feel that way! I simply think that not ALL people have the same taste in food. If a person doesn't like mexican food in the first place, they may not give the best review of a mexican restaurant and they may not disclose that they don't like mexican food. That's just an example, but you get what I'm saying. I think that if you come across consistent bad reviews, then it would be in your best internest to avoid the place.I'm referring to isolated incidences where you see one review claiming the food was bad but the entire menu interests you as well as the decorations and the theming. The Dis Unplugged has done a bunch of reviews and gave awfull feed back on three restaurants I quite liked and had zero of the same thoughts on. Tony's Town Square, the Coral Reef and Nine Dragons were three restaurants I actually quite enjoyed along with my sister and theyre three restaurants that consistenly get pretty bad reviews from Pete. Also, he has the ability to go to really nice places that my family can't exactly swing so some of the restaurants he dislikes may just not be to his taste but for us they're pretty good.
 
Understandable you feel that way! I simply think that not ALL people have the same taste in food. If a person doesn't like mexican food in the first place, they may not give the best review of a mexican restaurant and they may not disclose that they don't like mexican food. That's just an example, but you get what I'm saying. I think that if you come across consistent bad reviews, then it would be in your best internest to avoid the place.I'm referring to isolated incidences where you see one review claiming the food was bad but the entire menu interests you as well as the decorations and the theming. The Dis Unplugged has done a bunch of reviews and gave awfull feed back on three restaurants I quite liked and had zero of the same thoughts on. Tony's Town Square, the Coral Reef and Nine Dragons were three restaurants I actually quite enjoyed along with my sister and theyre three restaurants that consistenly get pretty bad reviews from Pete. Also, he has the ability to go to really nice places that my family can't exactly swing so some of the restaurants he dislikes may just not be to his taste but for us they're pretty good.


Food is personal. I know that my family enjoys Chef Mickey, and we all know how much love that restaurant consistantly does not get. We also think that Le Cellier is among the most overrated restaurants on property and after one meal there, have chosen never to go back. We like Tony's, and have found Coral Reef to be hit or miss, yet we still will consider it on occasion.

Disney dining is a combination of experience and tradition for many families, we are no exception. We tend to kick off our trip at Chef Mickey if we have kids or newbies with us, and will say farewell with breakfast at 'Ohana.
 
Food is personal. I know that my family enjoys Chef Mickey, and we all know how much love that restaurant consistantly does not get. We also think that Le Cellier is among the most overrated restaurants on property and after one meal there, have chosen never to go back. We like Tony's, and have found Coral Reef to be hit or miss, yet we still will consider it on occasion.

Disney dining is a combination of experience and tradition for many families, we are no exception. We tend to kick off our trip at Chef Mickey if we have kids or newbies with us, and will say farewell with breakfast at 'Ohana.

So true. My favourite meal for both food and atmosphere was our CRT breakfast, but I rarely hear any love for CRT, and if there is it is usually for the atmosphere. Also love Boatwrights and that one isn't mentioned often.
 
So true. My favourite meal for both food and atmosphere was our CRT breakfast, but I rarely hear any love for CRT, and if there is it is usually for the atmosphere. Also love Boatwrights and that one isn't mentioned often.

We love Boatwrights too! When we stay at POFQ we head over to BW for dinner, and never have we been disappointed.

We also liked Shutters a lot, yet that restaurant never seemed to get many positive reviews. We had booked Le Cellier on that trip, and had vowed never to bother again. We had to cancel our Epcot choice of COral Reef becuase our little one was exhausted, so when we got back to the resort I booked Shutters for dinner. It was among the best meals that trip.
 
All great tips!

I would emphasize the one tip that some PPs have mentioned: location. WDW is huge. And if you are visiting in hot, humid summer months, and also dealing with afternoon thunderstorms, find your eats either in or very close by to the park you are visiting that day. Don't crisscross property and take (planes), trains & automobiles just to eat. There are always very good options nearby. Your feet and your tired family will thank you.
 
That school bread was SICK. Me and my sister ordered it and we were both really disappointed
This is a perfect example of different tastes. I LOVED the school bread!! I'm not a huge sweets fan, but I would order this one again and again.

Love all the tips and advice on this thread. Thanks!
 
My biggest tip is the same one I give for all things WDW, don't over plan. Leave a few meals/days open. It is very easy to go with the flow, we have found some restaurants we wouldn't even thought of trying by simply getting on MDE in the middle of the afternoon and seeing what is available. There are days you just might not want a big sit down meal, we have been known to eat small plates in lounges on some days for our meal then just sort of snack the rest of the day (our idea of snacking is not popcorn or ice cream it's things like an order of nachos from the Mexico QS or fried rice for Yak and Yeti QS).

We never book ADRs any more in advance than 2 days and that is while we are actually there. This has always been our method and more often than not it's in the afternoon for that night. It helps if you have park hoppers and are loose with your other plans. We used to love to go to GS in the morning and either ask the CMs to find us something in x park after x time or find some at x time no matter where. We have had the CMs make a competition out of trying to see who can find us the most interesting place. Now days we do it via MDE, I just hop on there sometime in the afternoon and look for a certain time frame and go from there. Other than BOG, which we don't like, or the character meals we have been able to find plenty of places to eat.

Don't rule out resorts, they have some of the best restaurants on site and can be hidden gems. The week before Christmas we booked Mayan Grill at CSR while on the bus back to CSR for a half hour from the time we got on the bus.

We booked Chef's Paul for the same night one afternoon at about 5.
 
As we can see from feedback, location is a huge tip, for anyone who may be following this thread. Don't try to parkhop just for meals. I would say park hopping is nice for when you have a half day in one park and then finish out the evening in a different park. The pat two times my family and I have gotten parkhopper, we never used them. Seriously. some people need to have park hoppers, some people don't. It just depends. But dont get it just for meals.
 
My biggest tip is the same one I give for all things WDW, don't over plan. Leave a few meals/days open. It is very easy to go with the flow, we have found some restaurants we wouldn't even thought of trying by simply getting on MDE in the middle of the afternoon and seeing what is available. There are days you just might not want a big sit down meal, we have been known to eat small plates in lounges on some days for our meal then just sort of snack the rest of the day (our idea of snacking is not popcorn or ice cream it's things like an order of nachos from the Mexico QS or fried rice for Yak and Yeti QS).

We never book ADRs any more in advance than 2 days and that is while we are actually there. This has always been our method and more often than not it's in the afternoon for that night. It helps if you have park hoppers and are loose with your other plans. We used to love to go to GS in the morning and either ask the CMs to find us something in x park after x time or find some at x time no matter where. We have had the CMs make a competition out of trying to see who can find us the most interesting place. Now days we do it via MDE, I just hop on there sometime in the afternoon and look for a certain time frame and go from there. Other than BOG, which we don't like, or the character meals we have been able to find plenty of places to eat.

Don't rule out resorts, they have some of the best restaurants on site and can be hidden gems. The week before Christmas we booked Mayan Grill at CSR while on the bus back to CSR for a half hour from the time we got on the bus.

We booked Chef's Paul for the same night one afternoon at about 5.

Oh dear, this would make me a nervous wreck! LOL! I am not sure just what it means about me, but I am one of those folks who researches restaurants every where I go, and make as many reservations in advance that I can. THE same thing that is an albatross for some is a comfort for me.
 
I agree too wth the location. Eat at or by the park you’re at. Resort to resort travel by bus takes a long time, unless you’re driving or taking Uber/Lyft might not be worth it. Always take reviews with a grain of salt. Unless they are consistently bad, I don’t worry about them too much. People seem to complain more than give positive reviews. If something sounds good to you, go for it. I know food is expensive at DW, but don’t let a bad meal ruin your trip. If there is a problem, deal with it then, you’ll have a much better chance of getting it resolved.
 
I do not really listen to the bad reviews. I prefer to make up my own mind. I can have every person say they don't like a restaurant but until I try it for myself, I will not judge it. I can't say there are any that I would "never" go to again. However, I will NEVER eat the pizza again at Via Napoli. I did not enjoy the pizza there and everyone raves about it. If I went there again, it would not be for pizza. But I am trying different ones every trip. My only repeats have been BOG, Tusker House, CM and Kona Café breakfast. Otherwise, I try to book all new ones.
 
As we can see from feedback, location is a huge tip, for anyone who may be following this thread. Don't try to parkhop just for meals. I would say park hopping is nice for when you have a half day in one park and then finish out the evening in a different park. The pat two times my family and I have gotten parkhopper, we never used them. Seriously. some people need to have park hoppers, some people don't. It just depends. But dont get it just for meals.

This is good advice. I like a lot of restaurants at Disney World. I am among the people that really like BOG, CRT, etc. Even though I say I really like those restaurants, I would *never* think of park hopping to go there. I don't think there is any restaurant in a park worth the travel really. BOG is a good option if you are at MK anyway, not if you are at AK or a resort and need to travel to get there.
 


Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE








DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom