More Valuable: EMH vs VIP Tour?

coopersmom

DIS Veteran
Joined
Jul 16, 2010
Messages
839
So, we are currently planning our first family trip to Disneyland to check out Carsland this fall/winter (early Oct or Dec). We are looking at on-site and off-site hotel options and the conclusion I've come to is that we can either stay five-nights off-site in a suite (Hilton Anaheim), or four-nights on-site at the Disneyland Hotel in a regular room.

Even with the extra night, the off-site option is still about 60% of the cost of on-site (for a larger, likely more luxurious room), but doesn't come with the on-site perks, most importantly easy walkability and EMH. With Carsland being so new, the latter (EMH) is, honestly, what I'm most worried about losing.

Do you experts think that five-days is enough time that we won't have to worry so much about that extra morning hour in DCA? (This is my husband's thought, especially a few months from now when kids are back in school.)

Another idea is, with the savings from the off-site stay we could use VIP tour services for at least one day and still come out ahead, cost-wise. But, since I know that doesn't come with line-skipping potential, does that actually help us better tour California Adventure (we've never been to that park at all before), more efficiently enough to balance losing EMH? (As a Disney junkie I'm kind of interested in what a tour guide could tell us about the park; but not sure my son, 5, would be, though he'd love the attention.)

The final option is spending one night at a Disney hotel, to get EMH and use that to tour Carsland and do everything at least once, and then moving off-site for rest of the trip. The downside of this is, of course, the hassle in moving.

Any advice from DL experts about what they think will, or won't, work, and why? (And, yeah, I know with Carsland literally just days old at this point, it's hard to predict so, don't worry, I won't hold anyone to their speculation. ;)
 
I'm not sure about the first two options, but with the last one, I would recommend staying off-site first and then having the last night at a Disney hotel so that you end your vacation on a Disney-fied note.

What would also help us is how much of DLR have you already seen (is it just Carsland and BVS that you haven't?) and what are your kids most interested in seeing?
 
I'm not sure about the first two options, but with the last one, I would recommend staying off-site first and then having the last night at a Disney hotel so that you end your vacation on a Disney-fied note.

What would also help us is how much of DLR have you already seen (is it just Carsland and BVS that you haven't?) and what are your kids most interested in seeing?

My son had a one-day Disneyland trip last year, focused mostly on Fantasyland and Toontown (though we did ride Nemo) before heading out early afternoon. Our family has never been to California Adventure at all.

ETA: The reason I said Disney hotel first and then move off-site is because no way, no how are we going to be able to delay our son's Carsland frenzy until the end of a trip, so if we're staying on-site for DCA EMH aimed at better Carsland touring, it has got to be at beginning of trip :)
 
Assuming you are purchasing a park hopper ticket for 3 or more days, your ticket will come with one magic morning regardless of where you stay.
 

Assuming you are purchasing a park hopper ticket for 3 or more days, your ticket will come with one magic morning regardless of where you stay.

But that magic morning is only for DL. The OP is more interested in an early entry to DCA for Cars Land.
 
This fall/winter, things will have calmed down hopefully. We visited DLR last Thanksgiving and rode Star Tours numerous times *it had reopened last summer.
 
I'm not sure how fast the VIP tours fill, but if you are able to book a day or two in advance then I would stay off site and do as much as you can on your own. Then if you feel you need a VIP tour book it after spending some time at DCA then you haven't wasted the $ on something you did yourself.

I've never been on a VIP tour so I don't know if they are worth the $. To me I'd rather spend an extra day at the parks then on a tour.
 
If I was your son, I would want the extra day in the parks by staying at the off site hotel instead of one less park day and staying in a DLR hotel. Cars land will cool down in the fall/winter, making the EMH less of a necessity. As far as VIP tours, They are $125 per hour (Minimum 4 hours) when booked 48+ hours in advance and $150 per hour (Minimum 4 hours) when booked less than 48 hours in advance. I would go for park time rather than the tour and on site hotel. The planning process is so much fun!!!! I would encourage you to enjoy it as much as possible :)
 

New Posts



Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE









DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom