Minneapolis cabbies refuse service to Pasengers with dogs or alcohol.

DawnCt1

<font color=red>I had to wonder what "holiday" he
Joined
May 17, 2004
Messages
30,045
Some Muslim cabbies are refusing to serve airport passengers with dogs or unopened bottles of alcohol because it violates their faith. The officials at Minn. St.Paul International are trying to fight that.
www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=2007P1\05\story_5-1-2007_pg7

"Our presumption is if you are going to drive a taxi at the airport you need to provide service to anyone who wants it". I agree. What say you??

sorry, i can't get it to link. Its easily googleable.
 
I cannot see the article....

Is it those who consumed alcohol or carrying alcohol?

For the dogs--that one is easy...if they discriminate against the disabled or impaired. Tough noogies for them. Someone's accessory--then I don't mind at all as accessory pets aren't permitted in many places.

The alcohol is a toughy..but I don't understand the restriction.
 
Good for them. They should be able to refuse some fares. It's their loss.
 
so much for taking the cab home from the bar
 
I think any cabbie should be allowed to refuse any fare that's drunk or has a dog. I don't think they should be allowed to refuse a sober fare without a dog that's just transporting alcohol.
 
Good for them. They should be able to refuse some fares. It's their loss.

I suppose you would feel that way if you were bringing home an unopened bottle of wine from the airport, or you flew in from Boston with your toy poodle, or your guide dog, or your show dog for a dog show the next day. Isn't it reasonable to expect when you get off of a plane that you are not going to be discriminated against because of what you need to bring with you? If they don't want to service the airport, let them work elsewhere or find another job. If a Christian cabbie refused to pick up a Muslim, would you be so "understanding"?
 
I cannot see the article....

Is it those who consumed alcohol or carrying alcohol?

For the dogs--that one is easy...if they discriminate against the disabled or impaired. Tough noogies for them. Someone's accessory--then I don't mind at all as accessory pets aren't permitted in many places.

The alcohol is a toughy..but I don't understand the restriction.

Dogs and alcohol in any form are against Islam.
 
:rolleyes1

It's people WITH alcohol, not people who HAD alcohol.

ahh, so they dont mind driving drunks, they just dont want someone in there cab that has a bottle from the state store
 
I guess it comes down to "their loss". If they have a private cab, I guess they can refuse service to anyone they please. If they work for a company, I'm not sure how that would work. I do see them being ripped to shreds for refusing a service animal, but for just a pet, I think they have that right too.
As far as alcohol goes, isn't this stuff usually packed? Can you carry, even unopened, alcohol on a plane now? How would they know? :confused3 Even if in a carry on, I don't usually announce to anyone what I have in my bags, purse or other. Think they're just trying to :stir: to get attention?
 
I fly up there alot for work and almost every cab I've been in from the airport has been a Muslim. The strange thing is when I take the cab back from St Paul downtown to the airport, it's rarely a Muslim. So they must be more in Minneapolis.
 
I suppose you would feel that way if you were bringing home an unopened bottle of wine from the airport, or you flew in from Boston with your toy poodle, or your guide dog, or your show dog for a dog show the next day. Isn't it reasonable to expect when you get off of a plane that you are not going to be discriminated against because of what you need to bring with you? If they don't want to service the airport, let them work elsewhere or find another job. If a Christian cabbie refused to pick up a Muslim, would you be so "understanding"?
But surely they don't have the market cornered on taxi's do they? :confused3 I don't live there so I don't know. I guess I would be ticked off but I would just go find another cab, and if I knew that was an issue, I would look for a cab driver that looked more "passenger friendly" if you know what I mean. ;)
 
I guess it comes down to "their loss". If they have a private cab, I guess they can refuse service to anyone they please. If they work for a company, I'm not sure how that would work. I do see them being ripped to shreds for refusing a service animal, but for just a pet, I think they have that right too.
As far as alcohol goes, isn't this stuff usually packed? Can you carry, even unopened, alcohol on a plane now? How would they know? :confused3 Even if in a carry on, I don't usually announce to anyone what I have in my bags, purse or other. Think they're just trying to :stir: to get attention?

Even if it is a private cab, meaning privately owned, they still must have a public service license which requires that the public be served. In NYC, I would suspect that they would loose their license in a "New York Minute". It doesn't matter how the alcohol is packed or unpacked. They do not want to be in the presence of any alcohol.
 
Dogs and alcohol in any form are against Islam.

I don't really care...they need to find a new job in which they do not discriminate against those who NEED the assistance of a dog then.

Pets I am okay with...service animals--tough tomatos! Their cab is not a mosque (or whatever their religious building is called).
 
But surely they don't have the market cornered on taxi's do they? :confused3 I don't live there so I don't know. I guess I would be ticked off but I would just go find another cab, and if I knew that was an issue, I would look for a cab driver that looked more "passenger friendly" if you know what I mean. ;)

If you are waiting outside the terminal with all of your luggage, do you really think that someone with a license to taxi passengers has the right to refuse you because you aren't following their religious beliefs? Do you really feel that if its cold and snowing, that you should have to hail 2, 3 or 5 cabs before you find one willing to take you, your merlot and little FiFi?
 
I suppose you would feel that way if you were bringing home an unopened bottle of wine from the airport, or you flew in from Boston with your toy poodle, or your guide dog, or your show dog for a dog show the next day. Isn't it reasonable to expect when you get off of a plane that you are not going to be discriminated against because of what you need to bring with you? If they don't want to service the airport, let them work elsewhere or find another job. If a Christian cabbie refused to pick up a Muslim, would you be so "understanding"?


If you want to go there I be glad to note how interesting it is that you found another way to take a shot at Muslims.

I really do think it's always a case where they should be able to refuse a fare if they wish.

I don't think the service dog thing would apply since there are other options (other cabs). A person could have an alergy or other issues like this one.
 
I suppose you would feel that way if you were bringing home an unopened bottle of wine from the airport, or you flew in from Boston with your toy poodle, or your guide dog, or your show dog for a dog show the next day. Isn't it reasonable to expect when you get off of a plane that you are not going to be discriminated against because of what you need to bring with you? If they don't want to service the airport, let them work elsewhere or find another job. If a Christian cabbie refused to pick up a Muslim, would you be so "understanding"?

Personally I have never assumed an animal of any kind (other than service) could take public transportation (including cabbies).

If I was traveling with my pet or especially a show dog that pays for my livlihood...I would be prearranging transportation with a company where traveling with my pet would not be an issue.
 
ahh, so they dont mind driving drunks, they just dont want someone in there cab that has a bottle from the state store

Pop Daddy, I think it includes alcohol in or out of the bottle or in or out of the passenger.. ;)
 
Even if it is a private cab, meaning privately owned, they still must have a public service license which requires that the public be served. In NYC, I would suspect that they would loose their license in a "New York Minute". It doesn't matter how the alcohol is packed or unpacked. They do not want to be in the presence of any alcohol.
I swear to God I'm not trying to argue with you. I guess it's harder for me to understand because I fly into and out of Atlanta....and the number of transportation options are limitless. Also, lots of business have a license, but they also have signs that say they can refuse service to anyone. Again, if you're not announcing the presence of the alcohol....how will they know? Are they asking each fare if they're packing booze? I'm just trying to understand. And if someone did start questioning me as to what was in my private bags, I'd be finding another ride anyhow. I don't mind TSA taking a look, but no way in hell am I letting every and anybody start nosing through my stuff.
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom