Hi Kristen-
I live northwest of you and have taken a regular coach bus to NYC - once. After that trip, we decided that it's easier to drive and stay outside of the city and take the daily bus in to the Port Authority Bus Terminal. We go straight across I-80 into Secaucus, NJ and usually get a hotel on Priceline or Hotels.com for $75-90 per night in the Harmon Meadows area. My favorite is the Hyatt Place, but the Holiday Inn was also nice. Free parking or valet parking is available at both hotels.
The bus ride to the city takes under 15 minutes and is about $2.65 each way. My brother's family got a taxi from the same area and he thought that the price was also reasonable. There are also several restaurants within walking distance of the hotels.
I think the bus terminal in the city is between 38th and 42nd Streets on 8th Avenue, so it is close to shopping and shows. We usually shop in the Garment District, so we are able to walk wherever we need to go. If you need to venture further into other areas of the city, the subway and bus system offers an inexpensive "FunPass" with off and on privileges all day. When we're done, we simply go the the assigned gate for our bus at the terminal and we're back at the hotel very quickly.
We did fly into NYC out of Pittsburgh once and stayed across from Madison Square Garden. We thought that it was extremely overpriced and very noisy all night long (constant sirens and car horns). However, it was very convenient to walk around the city.
Have a great time when you go and try to check out the new
Disney Store that is supposed to open on Broadway at Times Square in early November.
Terri