Ok, I am glad you posted this - b/c we are leaving TOMORROW and seriously the baggage issue is so far the most stressing part of our travels.
First, we did not receive tags, even though I registerd online and got a confirmation email over 2 mos ago. Second, we arrive late (9 pm), so it could be after midnight that our luggage could actually show up. And since we are checking our pack n play, and will need that immediately, we might as well get all of our luggage (which I guess we actually have no choice since we didn't get tags).
This is our first family vacation, and first experience w/ this airport. DH and I will be traveling w/ DS6 (and his broken arm), DD4, and DD22mos.
So if anyone can give clear directions from AMERICAN airlines baggage claim, I will love you forever!