Totally out of date experience but I looked over our notes from our 2017 trip.
We went during Irma and it was the day before the airport was closing, we had a 1 hour delay in our home airport as MCO was halting all arrivals so planes could depart from MCO without issues.
Our plane (we flew SWA) landed at 11:30am got to gate at 11:40am, and we left the airport with our checked luggage and after getting a rental car (
Avis with skipping counter) at 12:30pm. In our case we went to Universal which is closer to the airport than Disney and arrived at the parking garage at Universal at 12:50pm. Looks like it was about an hour after landing that we left the airport.
I would plan for 1 1/2-2 1/2 hours to account for issues like staffing shortages getting luggage off the plane, longer taxing, ride share issues, etc but be okay if something happens where it takes longer than that.
Since you're planning to be at the parks that evening it may depend on what kind of ticket you have (AP where you can pop in for a few hours no worries, multi-day ticket where you're burning a park day with shortened time in the parks, etc), the time the park closes, etc as far as will the time be worth it.