I am planning a 4-day. And here is what I came up with.
I was like you, ready to give up Animators or Parrot Cay... But, after surfing the boards for a while I realized, Hey, that Master Chef's menu is not getting rave reviews. And, why miss out on the light show (especially with our son. ) or the tropical Parrot Cay, and then have to repeat a restaurant? I realized that I really wanted to go to Palo's on that last night. The best of all worlds! What a way to wrap up the cruise, a wonderful (and more quiet) relaxing dinner for the two of us, after a wonderful and relaxing day at sea... I plan on sending hubby to be first in line to get the PALO ressies for the time we want!