Well my choice would def be a Broadway person...
ADAM PASCAL (from Rent, Aida)
Joey McIntrye (played Fiyero in Wicked)
Barret Foa (was Princeton/Rod in Avenue Q)
Hugh Jackman (Boy From Oz)
but none of these four would ever happen.... Barret's gay (too bad... ALL the hot ones are! ugh), and Adam, Joey, and Hugh are all married. poopies. lol