My main thing against Galloway is the latter long runs that are SO long. Also I wonder if the two 30 minute runs mid week are sufficient. But I recognize these things work together.
Yes, the two short runs per week is sufficient, but as others have noted, these runs can be between 30-45 minutes. That being said, there is some more "stuff" in the runDisney experienced marathoner training plan.
I've heard Chris Twiggs, the national training director for Jeff Galloway, tell the story of how he found Jeff's training plan. He was a grad student, working three jobs, and have a 10+ mile run on a weekday. While he was doing it, he thought that there had to be a better way. The appeal of Jeff's plan is that you can just do those 3 days. Yes, the downside is the very LONG long runs, but that's what you have to do to get your evenings back during the week. That's a bargain that I will make every day of the week.
I am a back of the packer so I totally understand how long it takes to do the 20+ mile runs (my 26 mile runs take me between 7.5-8 hours). Personally, I just treat it like another day of work. I plan for it ahead of time and I tell the people in my life that I'm not available those days. As Nanci mentioned, once the numbers (and the time commitment) starts getting really big, they are only every 3 weeks.
I’m in the Galloway Customized group. My mid-week runs are usually 45 minutes. I do a cardio workout on one of my off days, usually a walk or pool run. The other two days I do strength training. And then my long run on the weekend (which is sometimes speed work). I was initially very hesitant about the super long runs, but after this month I only have one of them per month. So far, I’m enjoying the flexibility of the plan and not running a ton during the week. Also, some people do run an extra day, but do it easy. I’ve considered asking to put another easy run on my schedule, but I like having two days specified for lifting and another day for walking or swimming. It feels way more manageable.
Like Nanci, I'm also in Customized. Her post highlights the one thing that A LOT of runners miss about the Galloway plan. While you
can do 3 days a week, it is recommended that you do additional cross-training on at least some of the other days.
That’s a good idea to lengthen the mid week runs a little, especially when it cools off some.
I’m not doing anything besides running right now. I’m on my feet a lot at work, but no strength or anything. I know I should… but I haven’t committed to it yet. But good to know tweaking it a bit is possible.
Thanks guys! Okay! I think I’m gonna go with Galloway and try to add another mid week run after Labor Day. Maybe 30 min/3 miles/30 min. That sorta mimics the HH but I’ll leave it stable or maybe go up to 4 on the later weeks.
In Customized, the guidance that we get is that you can add an additional day of running, but if you find yourself running on tired legs, that's your body signal to drop the extra run day. Also, cross-training can be as simple as walking, aqua jogging (this is a super thing to do), or biking. With all of these, you get the benefits without putting additional pounding on your legs (and risking injury).
Then I’d feel better if I didn’t go to the full 26 beforehand
Just to throw this out there, I cannot tell you how mentally beneficial that 26 miler was for before my first marathon (and my second one). When things got very hard at Mile 23-24, I kept telling myself that I knew I could do it because I had already done it. Do people not go 26 miles before they do a marathon? Absolutely, all of the time! But as Jeff says "you're going to hit the wall at the longest distance that you've done in training." That's why when people talk about "hitting the wall," it is around Mile 20-21. If you're already spending the hours - and hours and hours - to get up to 20 miles or 22 miles or whatever, consider going the full distance just to get the endurance and the mental boost of knowing that you can go the distance. (Note: I do always leave the last .2 miles for race day)