Mama Melrose's vs. Tony's Town Square?

[AmberLuvsWDW]

Thank you for the vote for Mama Melrose.

We had a bad experience at Hollywood and Vine this year for our fantasmic dinner - so I am thinking of Mama Melrose.

We did the Fantasmic package at MM's. The food and service were excellent, but it was a big meal and took awhile. We ended up having to sit with the "General Population" at Fantasmic because we got out of the restaurant so late. That said, I would definately do it again, I would just be sure to make my ADR's a little earlier. (I think ours were for 6:30 and we still ran late.)

I have never eaten at Tony's so I can't say that MM's is better, but it is very good.

 

[PatriciaH]

Tony's is not good. Their breakfast used to be great though. If you go I would get soup and salad those are pretty good. MM has been great every time we went. I would also choose Alfredo's over Tony's any day. Or even Maccaroni Grill on 192