There are not many questions I am qualified to answer here, but this one I can lol.
We did both this summer and CP has LTT beat by much more than a mile IMO. In both the service was great. Atmosphere depends on what you like. I generally like quiet but I wasnt bothered by the noise in CP and I found the restaurant much more attractive, but thats a theming thing. The food at the CP was MUCH better than LTT I thought. Must better tasting and of course a much wider variety. I generally like Thanksgiving type of foods, but the stuff at LTT did nothing for me. My mom or even myself can make all of that meal much better. There honestly wasnt one thing that was near as good as my moms.