Looks like the Zimmerman story has more to it.

So here's the thing. You have someone directly involved in this that is gone. you have the other person who was directly involved in this and is he really going to say anything that would make him look bad?

What exactly did Zimmerman see or feel that was threatening about Martin? That he was black? That he had on a hoodie? Was he causing any problems? Was he lurking around people's houses or cars? Has he even really said WHY he felt Martin was suspicious? He was just walking through the neighborhood which last time I heard is allowed. This guy seems to think that anyone black who is in his neighborhood is 'suspicious'. We have seen this from previous reports he had called about.

Neighborhood watch is to WATCH. He supposedly saw someone he felt was a threat so why did he follow him at all? He called the police and told them and that was the extent of what his 'job' was. Instead despite being told they didnt 'need' him to follow Martin he did. At night. He never identified himself as neighborhood watch when confronted. Whether Martin confronted him or he confronted Martin we will never know for sure. I'm not sure what you would expect someone who is being followed by a man in a dark neighborhood to do? Run? Maybe but we are talking about a 17 year old and we all know how they are. Black or white

Is it possible that this 'witness' didnt see the beginning of this altercation? Maybe Zimmerman had Martin under attack first and Martin was able to get on top and that is when the 'witness' saw it. I mean seriously this is a mess because the other person is not here and cannot speak for himself. We only have the word of someone who killed someone. Would you in any way implicate yourself? I doubt that very much. Of course he has to make it look like he had to do it. Maybe he felt he did but we do NOT know who initiated the physical contact. So many are assuming based on what Zimmerman is saying and what one 'witness' saw and we dont even know at what point the witness saw the altercation

I really have a hard time understanding this 'Martin asked for this' mentality. He was walking through a neighborhood. He never asked to be followed and confronted by a stranger. So he had pot in his system. It stays in there for like 30 days and pot does not make you crazy. It just seems like reaching for justifications for Zimmerman to kill this kid and yes he is a kid compared to Zimmerman

I have a feeling he is going to get off on this and its a shame if it really didnt go down how he claims it did. Unfortunately we will never really know for sure since the only other person who could tell us is gone.
 
So here's the thing. You have someone directly involved in this that is gone. you have the other person who was directly involved in this and is he really going to say anything that would make him look bad?

What exactly did Zimmerman see or feel that was threatening about Martin? That he was black? That he had on a hoodie? Was he causing any problems? Was he lurking around people's houses or cars? Has he even really said WHY he felt Martin was suspicious? He was just walking through the neighborhood which last time I heard is allowed. This guy seems to think that anyone black who is in his neighborhood is 'suspicious'. We have seen this from previous reports he had called about.

Neighborhood watch is to WATCH. He supposedly saw someone he felt was a threat so why did he follow him at all? He called the police and told them and that was the extent of what his 'job' was. Instead despite being told they didnt 'need' him to follow Martin he did. At night. He never identified himself as neighborhood watch when confronted. Whether Martin confronted him or he confronted Martin we will never know for sure. I'm not sure what you would expect someone who is being followed by a man in a dark neighborhood to do? Run? Maybe but we are talking about a 17 year old and we all know how they are. Black or white

Is it possible that this 'witness' didnt see the beginning of this altercation? Maybe Zimmerman had Martin under attack first and Martin was able to get on top and that is when the 'witness' saw it. I mean seriously this is a mess because the other person is not here and cannot speak for himself. We only have the word of someone who killed someone. Would you in any way implicate yourself? I doubt that very much. Of course he has to make it look like he had to do it. Maybe he felt he did but we do NOT know who initiated the physical contact. So many are assuming based on what Zimmerman is saying and what one 'witness' saw and we dont even know at what point the witness saw the altercation

I really have a hard time understanding this 'Martin asked for this' mentality. He was walking through a neighborhood. He never asked to be followed and confronted by a stranger. So he had pot in his system. It stays in there for like 30 days and pot does not make you crazy. It just seems like reaching for justifications for Zimmerman to kill this kid and yes he is a kid compared to Zimmerman

I have a feeling he is going to get off on this and its a shame if it really didnt go down how he claims it did. Unfortunately we will never really know for sure since the only other person who could tell us is gone.


of course he'll get off, its Florida... just ask Casey Anthony. :sad2:
 
Trevon had every right to walk through that neighborhood.

George had every right to follow Trevon while he was walking the public streets.

George had every right to have a gun on his person while he was following Trevon provided he met the Florida requirements to do so (which it appears he did).

George did not have any right to start a physical altercation with Trevon. If he did so he broke the law.

Trevon had no right to turn around and start a physical altercation with George while he was following him, on a public street, even with a gun. If he did so George had every right to defend himself with lethal force. Again, it doesn't matter if Trevon was on top of him, hit him, gave him a concision, broke his nose, or anything else.

As soon as he came at me he would have been shot if I were in the situation to defend myself with a gun and I would not have had a single bruise or scar on me. The time to shoot is before you are physically attacked but are threatened with a physical attack.

It really isn't that hard. All the jury should really care about is who started the physical altercation. I have no idea and will wait for a jury to decide. The people stating George stalked Trevon really have no idea what actual stalking entails. Following is also not confronting.
 
Trevon had every right to walk through that neighborhood.

George had every right to follow Trevon while he was walking the public streets.

George had every right to have a gun on his person while he was following Trevon provided he met the Florida requirements to do so (which it appears he did).

George did not have any right to start a physical altercation with Trevon. If he did so he broke the law.

Trevon had no right to turn around and start a physical altercation with George while he was following him, on a public street, even with a gun. If he did so George had every right to defend himself with lethal force. Again, it doesn't matter if Trevon was on top of him, hit him, gave him a concision, broke his nose, or anything else.

As soon as he came at me he would have been shot if I were in the situation to defend myself with a gun and I would not have had a single bruise or scar on me. The time to shoot is before you are physically attacked but are threatened with a physical attack.


It really isn't that hard. All the jury should really care about is who started the physical altercation. I have no idea and will wait for a jury to decide. The people stating George stalked Trevon really have no idea what actual stalking entails. Following is also not confronting.

Then I hope you'd enjoy prison.

The law is the law. Self defense has requirements. Yes, it matters what happened. You do not have the right to use lethal force because someone starts a fight with you, nevermind how much you don't have the right because you're threatened with someone who might start a fight with you.

The idea that if someone turns and punches you (which in this case is not at all known to have happened or not), much less if you think they're going to punch you, you're legally allowed to kill them is ludicrous and I cannot even fathom where people get this notion.
 
Accoding to the Sanford police chief, GZ was on a personal errand that night and was well within his rights to be armed, which he was and thankfully so, it saved his life.

I agree with you that TM was under no obligation to speak to GZ or take orders from him. TM was also under no obligation to attack GZ, but it would appear that he did so anyway.

You mean the same police chief that stepped down after the way he handled this case? :rolleyes:
 
Either was George who was so afraid for his house he stalked this teen and shot him... ;)

I can debate facts but not this kind of baseless nonsense. GZ was ON THE PHONE with the police when he got out of his car. When the police asked him if he was following him, he said yes. When 911 told him he didn't need to do that (HE WASN'T TOLD STOP), he stopped and said he was walking back to his car. Where is stalking there? He remained where he was and TM came back around. Again, please define stalking? Im all for discussing facts and I like to know the reality. There is a lot to learn from situation like these. But we won't learn, and we will do ourselves and the justice system a disservice when we react in an emotional way, disregarding actual evidence.


Where are you getting the few inches or 18 at the most? Based on the CNN article I just posted above it lists it as "intermediate" range not close. From what I was just reading the categories are contact, near contact, intermediate and distant. I would think that a gunshot while you are allegedly pinned down by someone would be contact or at most near contact, right?

There is clearly conflicting info out there..not sure what source is to be "believed".

I watched 2 interviews with Florida attorneys yesteday saying intermediate was 1 in to 18 inches.

How many times has this "vigilant" citizen called the cops in the last few years again? he sounds more like a vigilante than vigilant!!

Vigilante? He was so well respected in his community that his fellow residents chose him as Neighborhood Watch CAPTAIN.

And Martin had every right to fear for his safety when face to face with the man "following" him.
Then why go back to find him?

Only if GZ did his "duty" as Neighborhood watched called the police, stayed home and let the police handle it not took actions into his own hands by following him. He would have been alive then too but no, GZ thought he had to protect himself by following TM? I dont understand HOW this can even be possible! :confused3

Again, lets talk facts. He was going to Target. Why should he "stay" home. In fact, the cops (yes the same ones that told him he didn't need to follow) were coming to meet him. At no point did the police say, GO HOME , we will meet you there. They seemed fine with GZ staying in the vicinity.

And GZ never said he had to protect himself by following TM. He had to protect himself from getting beat up.

What exactly did Zimmerman see or feel that was threatening about Martin? That he was black? That he had on a hoodie? Was he causing any problems? Was he lurking around people's houses or cars? Has he even really said WHY he felt Martin was suspicious? He was just walking through the neighborhood which last time I heard is allowed. This guy seems to think that anyone black who is in his neighborhood is 'suspicious'. We have seen this from previous reports he had called about.
Why? Because there had been numerous breakins in the neighborhood by kids fitting his description. Some had been arrested. I see someone, fitting description that I don't recognize, it might make me suspicious too. In fact, if you follow the released evidence, you notice the neighborhood newsletters mention the breakins and to please keep vigilant.

Neighborhood watch is to WATCH. He supposedly saw someone he felt was a threat so why did he follow him at all? He called the police and told them and that was the extent of what his 'job' was. Instead despite being told they didnt 'need' him to follow Martin he did. At night. He never identified himself as neighborhood watch when confronted. Whether Martin confronted him or he confronted Martin we will never know for sure. I'm not sure what you would expect someone who is being followed by a man in a dark neighborhood to do? Run? Maybe but we are talking about a 17 year old and we all know how they are. Black or white

Again,GZ ran after him to see where he was going while on the phone with the police. He stopped running when they suggested he do so. We don't know if he ever identified himself , do we?
. You ask if I expect him to run? I don't know but he DID run. That is exactly what he did. And yet, after losing GZ, TM turns back and goes looking for him
.

Is it possible that this 'witness' didnt see the beginning of this altercation? Maybe Zimmerman had Martin under attack first and Martin was able to get on top and that is when the 'witness' saw it. I mean seriously this is a mess because the other person is not here and cannot speak for himself. We only have the word of someone who killed someone. Would you in any way implicate yourself? I doubt that very much. Of course he has to make it look like he had to do it. Maybe he felt he did but we do NOT know who initiated the physical contact. So many are assuming based on what Zimmerman is saying and what one 'witness' saw and we dont even know at what point the witness saw the altercation

Yes, the crux of the matter here is who started the altercation. All we really know is what the girlfriend has said and what one witness has said.

I really have a hard time understanding this 'Martin asked for this' mentality. He was walking through a neighborhood. He never asked to be followed and confronted by a stranger. So he had pot in his system. It stays in there for like 30 days and pot does not make you crazy. It just seems like reaching for justifications for Zimmerman to kill this kid and yes he is a kid compared to Zimmerman

I don't see a "Martin asked for this " mentality. In fact I think its a very sad tragedy. Its not putting blame on Martin, its showing why Zimmerman fired in self defense. I, certainly, am not putting TM on trial, just giving reasons as to why I THINK Zimmerman is not some cold blooded vigilante killer and it was all a bad situation gone very bad.
 
Then I hope you'd enjoy prison.

The law is the law. Self defense has requirements. Yes, it matters what happened. You do not have the right to use lethal force because someone starts a fight with you, nevermind how much you don't have the right because you're threatened with someone who might start a fight with you.

The idea that if someone turns and punches you (which in this case is not at all known to have happened or not), much less if you think they're going to punch you, you're legally allowed to kill them is ludicrous and I cannot even fathom where people get this notion.


Uhhh because it is true? It is called self defense. You only have to feel threatened they don't have to touch you at all. And you won't go to prison.

And Firedancer is right, if I have a gun you are getting shot long before my head is getting smashed into the cement.
 
btw, do people remember Natasha Richardson? She fell and hit her head. No blood, no bashing, no gashes and she died. Hitting your head is serious business and you don't need it to be all cut up and bleeding for it to be dangerous. Its the internal injuries that matter. One bad hit is all it takes.
 
Uhhh because it is true? It is called self defense. You only have to feel threatened they don't have to touch you at all. And you won't go to prison.

And Firedancer is right, if I have a gun you are getting shot long before my head is getting smashed into the cement.

Exactly. When you pull back your fist to hit me you have committed assault. When you connect you have committed both assault and battery. The ideal is to stop the assault from becoming battery. I've made it 34 years without being punched and if I can keep that streak going I will.

Of course I don't own a gun and don't get into fights so it is a moot point, I'm not going to prison. I'm saying if I were in the position to do so I would. Nothing more. There is no reason to start a physical confrontation full stop.
 
I think we don't know the whole story. Let the jury decide when they get the evidence.
Pretty much. Unless you're sitting on the jury I don't see what difference speculation makes.

Nobody's outrage proved anything during the Casey Anthony trial. :confused3
 
So here's the thing. You have someone directly involved in this that is gone. you have the other person who was directly involved in this and is he really going to say anything that would make him look bad?

You would expect GZ to say things to make himself look good. But the thing is, most, if not everything in his statement has been corroborated by eyewitness statements or by the evidence. So on the few points where there are no witnesses or evidence to contradict or corroborate GZ, I would tend to believe his statement anyway. That along with some common sense conjecture based on the timeline, locations, etc, and his statement seems that much more accurate!
 
You would expect GZ to say things to make himself look good. But the thing is, most, if not everything in his statement has been corroborated by eyewitness statements or by the evidence. So on the few points where there are no witnesses or evidence to contradict or corroborate GZ, I would tend to believe his statement anyway. That along with some common sense conjecture based on the timeline, locations, etc, and his statement seems that much more accurate!

The bolded is not true. The witness statements are conflicting. Several heard an argument between the two. That's not consistent with Zimmerman's story that Martin came up from behind and punched him in the nose.

According to the EMT on scene, Zimmerman had a "small laceration" on the back of his head and all bleeding was minor. Is that really consistent with having his head repeatedly bashed on the concrete? Martin had one small cut on his left hand and a few scrapes on his right. Is that consistent with savagely beating someone?

The medical examiner's report says Martin was confronted by Zimmerman before the fight. I don't know where the ME got that information but, its still not consistent with Zimmerman's story.
 
The bolded is not true. The witness statements are conflicting. Several heard an argument between the two. That's not consistent with Zimmerman's story that Martin came up from behind and punched him in the nose.

According to the EMT on scene, Zimmerman had a "small laceration" on the back of his head and all bleeding was minor. Is that really consistent with having his head repeatedly bashed on the concrete? Martin had one small cut on his left hand and a few scrapes on his right. Is that consistent with savagely beating someone?

The medical examiner's report says Martin was confronted by Zimmerman before the fight. I don't know where the ME got that information but, its still not consistent with Zimmerman's story.

:thumbsup2:thumbsup2

The bold is a really good point.
 
According to the EMT on scene, Zimmerman had a "small laceration" on the back of his head and all bleeding was minor. Is that really consistent with having his head repeatedly bashed on the concrete? Martin had one small cut on his left hand and a few scrapes on his right. Is that consistent with savagely beating someone?

Why does it matter? People keep bringing this up but it is a moot point. You don't have to be beaten savagely to be in danger and defend you life. Someone sitting on you about to hit you is enough reason. Trevon's hands can be pristine as could George's head and face and it wouldn't mean the shooting was not justified. Of course if that was the case I would expect George to have said so. Lying just makes you look guilty.

Self-defense means you are allowed to defend yourself from being beaten. It doesn't mean after you are beaten a while you are allowed to defend yourself from being beaten some more. I make the assumption that anyone willing to hit me is willing to kill me. Only savages resort to physical violence (meaning throwing or gearing up to throw the first punch).
 
Why does it matter? People keep bringing this up but it is a moot point. You don't have to be beaten savagely to be in danger and defend you life. Someone sitting on you about to hit you is enough reason. Trevon's hands can be pristine as could George's head and face and it wouldn't mean the shooting was not justified. Of course if that was the case I would expect George to have said so. Lying just makes you look guilty.

Self-defense means you are allowed to defend yourself from being beaten. It doesn't mean after you are beaten a while you are allowed to defend yourself from being beaten some more. I make the assumption that anyone willing to hit me is willing to kill me.

:thumbsup2:thumbsup2
 
Why does it matter? People keep bringing this up but it is a moot point. You don't have to be beaten savagely to be in danger and defend you life. Someone sitting on you about to hit you is enough reason. Trevon's hands can be pristine as could George's head and face and it wouldn't mean the shooting was not justified. Of course if that was the case I would expect George to have said so. Lying just makes you look guilty.

It matters because as of now (his official statements haven't been released), that is his account of what happened. There are no witnesses to how or why the fight happened. All there is to go by is what he says happened. If neither of their injuries are consistent with his story, it calls that story into question.
 
Why does it matter? People keep bringing this up but it is a moot point. You don't have to be beaten savagely to be in danger and defend you life. Someone sitting on you about to hit you is enough reason. Trevon's hands can be pristine as could George's head and face and it wouldn't mean the shooting was not justified. Of course if that was the case I would expect George to have said so. Lying just makes you look guilty.

Self-defense means you are allowed to defend yourself from being beaten. It doesn't mean after you are beaten a while you are allowed to defend yourself from being beaten some more. I make the assumption that anyone willing to hit me is willing to kill me.


That piece of evidence is relevant, but what it means and how much weight it will hold remains to be seen.

And just because you were on the losing end of a fight and got a broken nose, does not necessarliy justify you killing the other person -- especially if you started the fight to begin with (which GZ may have done).

So the injuries on both people do have relevance in trying to figure out what went on during the altercation.
 
Why does it matter? People keep bringing this up but it is a moot point. You don't have to be beaten savagely to be in danger and defend you life. Someone sitting on you about to hit you is enough reason. Trevon's hands can be pristine as could George's head and face and it wouldn't mean the shooting was not justified. Of course if that was the case I would expect George to have said so. Lying just makes you look guilty.

It is indeed a moot point. I think it's crazy to assume that a person would have to wait till they were nearly dead to decide to use lethal force. Suppose Zimmerman had waited longer, then he could be concussed and beyond the ability to defend himself. In that time, in that moment, you don't have the luxury of time to wait and see. And again, being physically assaulted is a crime. From the evidence, Zimmerman appears he was getting his @ss handed to him by a younger, stronger 6' young man.

I'm a woman, suppose I was propositioned in an alley by someone. He makes a move towards me, roughs me up a bit and I'm supposed to wait till I'm really seriously hurt to make a move to defend myself? Ludicrous. And yes I know these circumstances aren't entirely comparable but still. Nobody has a right to physically assault someone.

Bottom line is that IMO, the evidence thus far points to Zimmerman's account being true. The location, the injuries, the 911 calls, etc. I'm going to go out a limb here and even state that it was most likely clear to the arriving officers and upon further compilation of evidence, they still didn't charge Zimmerman with anything. Not until it became a media ruckus screaming racial profiling did they decide to turn it over and charge him.
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom