Live 8 Opinions

AlanUK

<font color=blue>UK Trip Planning & Trip Reports M
Joined
Apr 25, 2004
Messages
2,936
Well Saturday has been and gone and those of us that watched all or even part of the concert must have some opinions on who we liked/disliked so I thought we would have a new thread to discuss :teeth:

Personally I thought all the acts put on a good show with the small amount of time they were given. I was particularly impressed by The Who who really rocked and looked like they were having a great time performing. I was a little disappointed that the Killers only managed to perform one song :( and I couldn't work out why Mariah Carey needed someone to personally lift a bottle of water with a straw in it up to her mouth so that she could have a drink???? :confused: Is she allergic to plastic bottles? ;)

The funniest moment of the day had to be when Snoop Doggy Dogg just let rip with all the 'Mother Loving' in the middle of his act. I had a mental image of a frantic BBC production team trying to decide what to do with the broadcast :teeth:

What were your thoughts???
 
I watched it from begining to end and thought it all great. I particularly liked The Who, Pink Floyd, Scissor Sister, Annie Lennox, Robbie Williams, Madonna, Travis and Coldplay. Sadly, I remember The Who and Pink Floyd from the 60's so it was a real nostalgia trip for me.

I think Bob Geldof and Co did a fantastic job arranging it at such short notice and hope it does some good.
 
I watched it on TV and thoroughly enjoyed it. My personal faves were Madonna and Annie Lennox ( I fear I am showing my age here LOL!) I must say I was disappointed Status Quo did not open the event, (do you know why they weren't there?), and although I am sure the opening must have been very meaningful with Paul McCartney and U2 performing together, the effect was lost on me as my DD's age 10 and 8 caught sight of the "Sergeant Pepper" men and shrieked "Look! It's the 118 men dressed up!":rotfl2:

I saw a little of the Philadelphia concert and really enjoyed the Kaiser Chiefs, a band that really takes me back to my (misspent:rotfl: ) youth!
 
Highlight for me was the Philly show - Bon Jovi :love: :love: Those trousers JBJ was wearing were just :faint:

Thought all the shows were incredible, what I saw, and thoroughly enjoyed every minute.

Sorry Robbie Williams fans out there - the radio was raving about him, but thought he was only "ok", same for Elton John.
 

Mrs Dazzle said:
Highlight for me was the Philly show - Bon Jovi :love: :love: Those trousers JBJ was wearing were just :faint:

Me too.... Jon Bon :love: I did say to DH - that I think Jon is the only man in the world who could get away with those trousers :) Liked there new song too!
 
Both DS and I thought The Who were outstanding but neither of us can see the fuss about Pink Floyd (and I never could). Thought Robbie and Madonna gave first rate performances too. I also enjoyed watching Greenday play in Berlin. Sadly I missed Paul McCartney and hope he did justice to 'Hey Jude' :sunny:
 
I enjoyed pretty much all of it really! :teeth:

The Who were fantastic and I especially liked R.E.M., Scissor Sisters, Annie Lennox, Keane, and Snow Patrol from the rest. I thought Pink Floyd were really good in a nostalgic way, but maye not much else!

Although I thought Madonna gave a great performance, I really disliked her attitude of "This is me performing for you and you have to show how much you appreciate me doing this". Didn't she understand people were there for many reasons ad maybe not all of them actually even like her music very much? :confused3 Also, Elton John is one of my favourites but I didn't think much of his set on Saturday :(

I couldn't work out why Mariah Carey needed someone to personally lift a bottle of water with a straw in it up to her mouth so that she could have a drink???? Is she allergic to plastic bottles?
LOL :rotfl: :rotfl2:
 
i had a stall at the school fete all afternoon so only caught some of the evening performances. Thought Madonna was fantastic - the best act I managed to see. Liked Scissor Sisters and Killers - I too was disappointed that they only did one song. Watched up to and including Sting who I also thought was good. Maria Carey - way too sickly for me I'm afraid! And was Pete Doherty as bad as the papers have said he was? I've tried looking for somewhere to download his bit but no luck as yet.
 
Pete Doherty was awful, he looked like he had no idea where he was or what he was doing. In all honesty he probably didn't know considering the things he likes to put in his body :( It's so sad, I met him 3 years ago just before the Libs put out their first single and he was lovely and chatty and sang great - a lesson in what drugs do to you...

My favourite band was easily Velvet Revolver, Jonathan Ross's comments afterwards were hilarious "it's ok, you can come out now, they've gone"! I also loved Kaiser Chiefs, The Who, U2, The Killers, Scissor Sisters, Bon Jovi, Elton John, REM and Green Day. Pink Floyd were good but I can't see what the fuss is about either (unlike my mother who thinks they are the best band in the world.)
 
I didn't catch all of it but was very impressed with Madonna, The Who, Pink Floyd (though not a big fan but they are fantastic musicians), U2, Annie Lennox, Scissor Sisters, Killers (shame only did 1 song) & Craig David in Paris -great voice.
Missed REM and Snow Patrol and also Robbie who I have been told was excellent. Loved Velvet Revolver and thought Slash was a real showman.
 
I should have tivo-ed it, but only caught the last 10 minutes.

What was LIve 8 for? What was the charity?
 
It was to highlight the meeting this week at Gleneagles of the G8 - the 8 richest countries in the world - top of the agenda will be cancelling debt owned by countries in Africa and increasing aid.

There are various marches also taking place in Eindburgh. I see from the news this afternoon that the loonies have been on the streets of Edinburgh causing trouble. Lets hope the police sort them out because all they will do is destroy all the good that has been done over the past few days.

Maybe those morons causing damage and fighting the police should be sent to Africa and forced to help those poor people who want to make a better life for themselves.

Would certainly be a far better punishment than a slap on the wrist or a fine that mummy or daddy would pay anyway
 
It wasn't actually for a charity as such. It was to raise awareness and to put pressure on the G8 leaders who are meeting in Edinburgh this Wednesday. Bob Geldof etc want Africa's debts written off and for them to be able to trade freely - I think, maybe someone else will be able to clarify the trade issue.
 
From the Make Poverty History Website...

ROBBED, RIPPED OFF and RUINED...

Something is very wrong with world trade - it's filling the pockets of the rich while ripping off the world's poorest people. Why is this happening? What can we do? Read on to find out why MakePovertyHistory is calling for Trade Justice.

Millions of people are stuck in the trade trap. No matter how hard they work, they earn less every year. The situation is so dismal, half the world's population now lives on less than US$2 a day - roughly the cost of a burger.

Why are people cheated of a proper living?

Trade rules:

You may not be aware of them, but trade rules control how countries do business with each other. They are agreed at international level, and are supposed to make sure nations compete openly and fairly.

In reality they don't.

That's because the rules are rigged - loaded in favour of the wealthiest countries and their business interests.

So no matter how hard people work in the developing world, or how much their countries produce, trade relationships benefit the rich world most.

The result is misery for hundreds of millions of people who just want the chance to make a living, feed themselves, send their kids to school and create a better future for the next generation.

So who's behind these unfair trade rules?

A handful of big international organisations set the rules and policies controlling the way we trade.

The problem is policies aren't decided democratically, but on the basis of who has the most economic clout. While paying lip-service to fairness, the richest countries, with their almost limitless resources, steer decision-making in their interests.

Poor countries lose out time and again.

Meet the big boys

Three main bodies combine to write the rules of trade:

World Trade Organisation (WTO)
World Bank
International Monetary Fund (IMF)

All three are dominated by the world's richest nations.

What are they doing?

Between them, they're forcing poor countries to open up their markets to foreign imports and businesses, and sell off public services like electricity - even when this isn't in their interest. They're also banning poor countries from supporting vulnerable farmers and industries, while wealthy nations continue to support their own.

All this is being done in the name of 'liberalisation' - and 'free trade' or leaving things to market forces.

The fall out

Developing countries are getting hammered.

Livelihoods are going to the wall, as farms and businesses go bust, unable to compete with a flood of cheap, subsidised imports.

Governments are losing control of basic public services, as they're snapped up by profit-hungry investors. And workforces are being cynically plundered for cheap labour by powerful, under-regulated transnational companies, leaving thousands open to abuse and exploitation.

What can we do?

It's simple really, change the rules. Now.

It's an obvious solution - challenge and change the rules so they work for poor countries. Re-write them in favour of the poorest countries so they can develop, build their own industries, grow stronger, and one day compete as equals.

Rich countries used trade rules to protect themselves as they developed - which is how they got where they are now. We consider it fair to use trade rules to end world poverty as we know it.

Who's listening?

Governments are listening - the call for fairer trade rules grows every day and it's becoming impossible to ignore.

And governments can actually do something. They have ultimate control over the WTO, IMF and World Bank - because they have more say in negotiations than anyone else.

And our own government? The UK is in a uniquely strong position to influence trade rules this year. As President of the European Union and meeting of world leaders (known as the G8), they have a once in a generation chance to show leadership on beating poverty.

The time is right. The rules must change. Help us press home the message.

Make poverty history, and join us.

more information can be found at http://www.makepovertyhistory.org
 
Both DH & I both think The Who were excellent...and in the US gotta say Stevie Wonder :)
 
I didnt see all of it as me and dd went to theatre to see beauty and the beast.
Well i have to agree Bon Jovi were great!! (nice trousers ;) )
also liked robbies performance!! :cool1:
 
Scissor Sisters were good, although for the first two songs I couldn't hear her - so much so that I thought she was miming at first, but then I couldn't hear him on the final song. Anyone else feel that? Dh also enjoyed Velvet Revolver, but the jury's still out for me.

Agree with Hilary about Madonna - she just didn't seem to comprehend that she had been invited to be part of something much bigger. Hello! Not everything is about you, love. Also, although she is a great performer, her voice isn't the best - I guess Elton was right about her.

For me, though, the absolute standout act was The Who - everyone else paled into insignificance. They were superb. Mind you, I did miss most of Pink Floyd - we were watching Motley Crue in Canada. (That is, they were in Canada. We were in our living room :teeth: ).
 
I watched nearly all the Hyde Park concert and enjoyed nearly all I saw, even stars/groups I've not really bothered with before.

I especially enjoyed REM, Keane, Scissor Sisters, Dido, Annie Lennox, Travis, Snow Patrol and Velvet Revolver with Slash. The Who and Pink Floyd really rounded the day off :)

Pete Doherty was a complete tosser and shouldn't have even been allowed in
London, never mind on stage!

Madonna was OK - shame she had to lower herself to using the F word though.

I saw Craig David in France and he was great - how does he sing so fast!

I didn't realise that Mariah Carey had such fat legs :)
 
Saw most of it and loved what I saw, stand out acts for me were, Coldplay, Keane,The Who,Robbie Williams and Snow Patrol but I was a little bit dissapointed with the sound quality of Snow Patrol. Also thought Madonna was out of order with the F-Word.

And a round of applause has to go out Peter Kay for effort :rotfl:


Sue :wave:
 
Favourite bits - Robbie, Sting, scissor sisters (even though there was something off with her mic!) I was just off to bed when Jon Bon Jovi appeared in his trousers, or maybe it was just a special kind of textured paint? and all thoughts of sleep fled

I loved 'queen hands' to 'Road to Amarillo' too.

It's worth a good look around the world vision site too. I know this was a political event, but you can go online and donate blankets or chickens etc. Or even sponsor a child. I've talked to my 2 boys (7 and 9) and they've decided while we've got so much compared to other people in the world they are going to donate some of their pocket money each month to sponsor a child. :grouphug:
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter
Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom