LeCellier or Tutto Italia w/o DDP

[ProudMommyof2]

If you had to pay out of pocket- which would you choose for 2 adults 2 kids?

 

[MeLaNie9]

While I will say that LeCellier was our favorite on our Dec 07 trip, this past Dec it was just horrible (service was absolutely terrible, my cheese soup was like a salt lick and entree was virtually inedible). We were very impressed with Tutto. The food was delicious and it was one of our favorite meals. The service was fantastic. So for food quality/taste and service, after our last trip experience, I would recommend Tutto!

 

[minniebeth]

If you had to pay out of pocket- which would you choose for 2 adults 2 kids?

They are both good, but Tutto Italia is VERY expensive to pay OOP with.
When we ate there, we had 1 child appetizer, 2 pasta main courses and two iced teas with a complimentary birthday dessert. With tax and tip if was well over $80. (Dinner....Lunch may be a little more inexpensive.)

I can't compare it with LC because when we ate there, we were on the DP, so I honestly don't remember the cost.

Both are so enjoy!

 

[colinsdad]

Let me say just this for OOP.

Tutto Italia is the best DDP TS credit you can use in WDW for a child because you get an app $6, Entree $9, drink $2.50, and dessert $5. $22.50 is about the most value you can get with a child single TS credit.

But I digress because you don't have to order an appetizer or dessert for your child.

A kids meal at Le Celier runs $7.49 and includes drink and dessert. Add $2.00 and your kids can have steak. You'll spend at least $11.50 as noted above at Tutto for an entree and drink (maybe more if the kids would like dessert).

Adult entrees are similar in price but at Tutto you can have a $24 Lasagne while at Le Celier you can have entrees like a $26 Prime Rib.

We did both last trip, but we were on the DDP. If I was paying OOP, I would do Le Cellier because I feel its a better value (steak vs. pasta for the same or higher price at Tutto). Whatever you decide will be delicious though. Enjoy.

 

[devonsmommy]

We ate at both on our last trip in September and I like Le Cellier much better. If you can get in Le Cellier, that's what I would do.

 

[TruBlu]

They are both fantastic, so which ever you pick you should be happy. I'd say that for the money I'd have to choose Le Cellier - but honestly, I love them both. Check out the menus and pick the one that sounds better to you. I think it would be worth a few more $'s to go with the one you find more appealing.

 

[gr8tdame]

Le Cellier ....most definitely.

 

[antmaril]

Tutto Italia is very good, but it is expensive. My friend and I had lunch there less than two weeks ago. I had lasagna and she had a pasta dish. We both had coffee -- $57.89 (including tip).