I voted for the Strip, as it was amazing. I used to love the filet when it was the BBQ-maple glaze, but unfortunately they don't serve that anymore. On our last visit there our server recommended the NY Strip over the (mushroom) filet, but like an idiot I went with the filet instead, because of all the great reviews of it. Well I should have listened to her because: The filet tasted pretty bland, although fork-tender as usual. I tried my son's NY Strip, and it was Oh My Gosh sooooo delicious! I'm definitely getting that next time.