kids out of school- better at beginning or end of year?

Ariel on Land

DIS Veteran
Joined
Jun 30, 2008
Messages
1,421
I'm sure this has been discussed before, so humor me for starting another thread about it, but this will be our first time taking the kids out of school for a trip since they start Kinder this fall. We're looking at possibly taking a trip next fall (Sept) or late this spring (end April/beg May). For those of you who have done it, or any teachers out there-- what are the pros/cons? Touring-wise, we'd rather go in Sept. Plus flu season should not be in effect yet, and our DD will be a little over 2, so she might be able to enjoy the trip a little more. But I wonder if May is better school wise? If the teacher doesn't like it, well our kids will only have to deal with them for another month, whereas in the fall, they'll have the rest of the year. Plus, in the fall, there's no way to predict if the kids will have a particularly bad year w/ illness and other unexpected absences. :confused3

WDYT?? Thanks!

Edited at bottom- but basically, would October or November make a difference vs. Sept??
 
We've taken our kids out of school for Disney several times. We did once in September when DS was in 1st grade. He was out for a week. It was harder for him to adjust coming back since it was at the beginning of the school year, but it's a great time to go even though the weather is still pretty warm.

The other times we've taken them out the end of January at the end of the schools quarter. The kids have 2 teacher workdays then and we take them out for 3 days before the workdays plus the weekend, so we stay almost a week. We've done it the past 2 years and it's the best time for us to go. The weather is cooler and the crowds are lighter. It is also free dining sometimes so that's a plus for us! I'm planning on doing it again this year. It's the end of the quarter so they aren't learning anything new and it's a nice break from the winter weather.

I've never taken them out in April/May so I'm no help there. Whatever you choose have a great trip!
 
As a former teacher, I think September would be harder to adjust. Our schools do state testing the 2 weeks after Spring Break (which makes no sense but there it is). Therefore, the last week of April and all of May are simply reinforcement of learned skills and introduction to concepts from the next grade. My DH has a thing about never taking kids our of school for vacations, but I would have no issue with a late April/May trip because I know not much gets accomplished after Spring Break and testing.

BTW, our B/G virtual twins start kindergarten as well. :)
 
We used to take DD out and go in May which is our absolute favorite time. The crowds are low, weather is nice and we loved the Flower & Garden festival. Due to testing at he end of the school year we started pushing it to the last week of the month which was fine. Crowds built around Memorial Day weekend but it was manageable. Plus, we got to see SWW. I say May is perfect and you should give it a try.
 
I am a teacher and would agree with those who said a spring trip would be better. It is really hard for students to miss time in the fall. Do try to find out when any testing takes place, though...this is the most difficult to schedule around.

Kim
 
Do some states test in kindergarten?
I would say that testing time would be good for kindergarten in my district because our schedule is so messed up to accommodate testing.
 
Thanks for all the responses!! Seems as spring is overwhelmingly the answer. Bummer for me... I wanted fall! ;) But I think I probably was expecting the answer to be spring.

Although I do have another question, instead of September, what if we waited until October or early November? Would that make a difference? Thanks!! Y'all are so helpful! :thumbsup2
 
Thanks for all the responses!! Seems as spring is overwhelmingly the answer. Bummer for me... I wanted fall! ;) But I think I probably was expecting the answer to be spring.

Although I do have another question, instead of September, what if we waited until October or early November? Would that make a difference? Thanks!! Y'all are so helpful! :thumbsup2

Do your kids have any days off in Oct or Nov? My kids have Columbus Day off and the Friday before. I'm planning an Orlando trip then(Universal or WDW, haven't decided yet). We'll fly out on Thurs after school, get in Orlando late, then start at rope drop on Friday. We'll come home on a later flight either Monday night or Tuesday night. But, my kids are older than yours (they are in Jr. High). They are easy to travel late at night.

Have you done the Halloween party? Your kids will love it!

Another note: your kids are only in kindergarten. I wouldn't worry about pulling them out of school.

Why not do WDW in October for the Halloween party, and then go to Disneyland in California in Jan/Feb? lol!!!
 
For Kindergartners, I don't think it makes that much difference. Having said that...

I would not take them out too near the beginning of the year. As a teacher I know that it can be very difficult for kids to settle in to the class routines if they missed that period of establishing routines. This can be even more true for little ones.

My favorite trip ever was late April/early May. Be sure that you check into your school's attendance policy. If your children miss a lot due to illness, it could be possible that you do not have time off left for a vacation late in the year. In the district where I teach, you must have a Doctor's excuse after 10 absences- no exceptions. Basically, if you took a vacation before your child had been out much then you would be fine if they got sick later since you could get a Doctor's note for the later absences. If they were sick throughout the year, though and you wanted a vacation late in the year it's possible to get in truancy trouble since you couldn't get the doctor's excuse.

If your school would allow for vacation or is easy going about absences then my first choice would be April/May. Second choice...October.
 
Remember, it's Kindergarten. I think you shoud just go whenever you want to. Children are very adaptable. The kids will probably remember some things from the trip but won't remember that they missed learning about the letter "c" or butterflies.
 
Remember, it's Kindergarten. I think you shoud just go whenever you want to. Children are very adaptable. The kids will probably remember some things from the trip but won't remember that they missed learning about the letter "c" or butterflies.
LOL - I don't know, kids these days are learning a lot more in kindergarten than I remember learning when I was 5! :rotfl: My oldest has been reading fluently now for 2 years - and he's not even 7 yet.

In all seriousness, I would personally avoid a September vacation with a child just entering kindergarten because that's when the kids learn all of the routines in the classroom and that's one of the most important skills a "new" student can learn. I would definitely pick October or November over September.

We are going in November, and will be taking the our son out of 2nd grade for 4 days. We spoke with his 1st grade teacher when making the plans and were advised that many families in our school district take their kids on vacation that week because there are several consecutive days where schools are closed between election day and veterans day, and the teachers don't do much in the classroom during those two weeks as a result.

I think regardless of when you go, your children will be fine if you work with their teachers to prepare for the work they'll miss when they are out of school. You should go whenever it is best for you and your family.

BTW, we went in April once and the weather and crowds were both great! I am a little concerned it will be cold in November.
 
As a teacher I say go whenever you can, but in regards to Sept. or May, I would have to vote for May. Sept. is a big transition to a new grade, and so much is done to teach procedures and getting to know each other that it would be a shame for your child to miss this important part of the year.
 
Thanks for all the responses!! Seems as spring is overwhelmingly the answer. Bummer for me... I wanted fall! ;) But I think I probably was expecting the answer to be spring.

Although I do have another question, instead of September, what if we waited until October or early November? Would that make a difference? Thanks!! Y'all are so helpful! :thumbsup2

Our school district has a fall break in early October--that's when we plan to go in 2014. If your school doesn't have that, but has a long weekend or 2-3 days off in Oct/Nov, maybe you could schedule around that to minimize days missed.
 
When is their first day? If they start in mid- August then late September/early October shouldn't be a problem.
 
I use to take my son out of school the beginning of September but when he came back he was like the "new kid" in school and had to start over. I now take him out the end of Sept/beginning of Oct. His school is only retouching on the stuff they learned last year at that time of year. Since he is an honor student I'm sure he doesn't mind missing what he already knows.

We have also done the end of Nov/beginning Dec.
 
Take them at the beginning of the year. At the beginning, they are still reviewing from last year and haven't learned to much new stuff yet. They also won't have as much homework.
 
I am pulling my daughter out of school in mid September for a week to go to Disney. She will have been back in school for 6 weeks at this point and I think should be very comfortable in her routines. She will be in 2nd grade and I personally think it shouldn't be a huge deal. We can't pass up low crowds and MNSSHP!!!
 
I am using the 2 consecutive teacher work days and will only have the kids miss the 3 prior to them for our Nov trip!
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom