Susy, I understand everything you are saying. This is personal for you. But you do admit it's speculation, and I don't see you spewing out hate. What you are saying, imo, leaves room for a discussion.
I could be 100% wrong, but I'd like to think that Kate has learned from how she and Jon treated each other. She seems softer to me, and I think the kids may benefit from that. You are right that we don't know if that is how they betrayed her...if so, they certainly hit their mark and have turned Kate into a celebrity because of how they betrayed her.
I'm sorry about how your mom was, but we do have to remember that none of us really know Kate, and everyone deserves a chance. Hating someone we don't even know, just isn't good for any one of us. In fact hating anyone isn't good. I wonder if watching Kate and reading this board is something that helps you or harms you, if she is so much like a mom that gives you bad memories...doesn't it dredge up memories you might be better off trying to put behind you (and I really do mean that in a nice way)?
I really appreciate how nicely you posted what you did. And believe me, while I may be 'pro-Kate' there is a lot that she has done that I haven't liked, just like with many others that have been in the public eye. But I also believe she really does love her children, and I do hope that we are just not shown the in between times, when she shows them that. Too me, when they do something wrong, I don't see fear in their eyes, the times we do see them, and for me that is a good thing.
The thing with kids, and I'm not excusing your mom at all, is they don't come with instructions and most of us are trial and error, and do the best we can. Often other's who don't have kids (or haven't had a teenager yet) are positive they can do a better job, and who knows, maybe they could. There were times when I wish I could have turned mine over to someone else. Luckily, in spite of my mistakes, they all turned out wonderful.
I think that many of us who are anti-Kate have been wounded by someone similar in our lives. Obviously, I know NOTHING about her that I haven't seen on tv or read online. All of that could be edited against her. However, what I do see reminds me so much of my mother that I can't help projecting my mother's traits onto Kate and assuming she is similar all around. Is that just speculation? Of course! But what I've seen over and over and over reinforces in my mind how Kate likely really is. Constantly belittling the husband and seeing nothing wrong with it, repeatedly putting her own needs and wants above those of her children, I could go on and on...
Doris, the reason your pro-Kate comments sometimes aggravate me is because I know firsthand how damaging my mother's behavior was to my father, brothers and me. And we weren't on tv or in any public situation. We weren't physically abused, she wasn't an alcoholic or drug addict, etc. So many have had it so much worse! However, it was tough growing up knowing my mom wanted a perfectly trained showdog instead of me. It was hard to take the constant belittling and even harder to hear my dad being put down every second of his life. It was just plain weird to realize mom's entitlement was completely unjustified. It is impossible for me to not draw parallels between my mother and Kate. It is also impossible for me to not speculate that the kids (and Jon) have been hurt by her behavior. It's offensive to me when others (general others) act like Jon deserved his poor treatment or the kids won't be harmed by Kate's awful behavior.
I'm sure Kate (like my mother) has plenty of wonderful qualities. I have no problem with her working away from home because I would have LOVED it if my mom went away for days or weeks at a time, especially if I was left with a twentysomething babysitter! I agree that Kate needs to work every opportunity she gets and earn every penny she can before she fades into oblivion. As for the kids, I hope they somehow make it through this fiasco with as little damage as possible!