I found the beds at Park Vue very comfortable. I liked HOJO as well, but personally I don't prefer one to another.
As for the person who couldn't talk to the manager, I find that very strange as everyone was so helpful all the time. I also had a question about the charges on my bill, but there was some kind of $2 a night hotel surcharge or tax that made a $16 discrepancy, but when I called, they explained it very well and told me there was an explanation on the invoice, which there was.
I found that everyone was bending over backwards to please us and super polite at all times.
Perhaps that was an off day. Certainly management is aware that negative reviews spread quickly and I even talked about it with on of the fellows about it. He said that they had now renovated all the rooms so that all the carpets were clean and they spent extra time cleaning (which I found to be true).
I'm sure there will always be negative experiences everywhere. I didn't find my stay at the
Disneyland Hotel that wonderful, there was a broken door to my closet, the a/c wasn't working properly, and they double booked our room so when we went in it there was another family already there! However, these things happen and I wouldn't tell anyone not to go there because of those things.
Certainly the water park is fantastic at the HOJO, and if you have small eaters and get the entertainment rate, its a great deal. We enjoyed our stay there as well. There are pros and cons to all hotels, I just think that all things considering, Park Vue tops them all.
PS I also stayed at the Fairfield Inn too, which I had forgotten to mention.