You're welcome -- these boards were a great source of inspiration for our first cruises, so I'm happy to do my part
We did rent ahead of time, and I've already booked online for our November cruise. We booked a Vitara in St. Marten again, this time at Budget because it is so convenient. Just went to
www.budget.com and did it from there. Click Find Location, go to St. Martin as the country, Philipsburg as the city, and pick the cruise terminal location. Couldn't be simpler.
If you choose to use
Avis in St. Thomas, you can also book online at
www.avis.com, which is what we did last year. It may cost a little more, (I don't know that it does, but I have read of others bargaining for rentals on the day of arrival) but I like the assurance of having a confirmed reservation at a brand name location.
Good luck . . . and have fun!