DF and I are trying to decide between POFR and POR for our honeymoon trip in late August. Would someone please help us out by comparing the two in terms of a relaxing, quiet, and romantic atmosphere? I assume FQ has less hustle and bustle since it's smaller, but I'd rather have people's take based on first hand experience. Thanks a million!
IMHO, POR wins hands down. I'm actually talking about the Alligator Bayou section of POR. Because POR is bigger, I think that makes it seem less crowded also. I haven't stayed in Magnolia Bend so I'm not sure of the atmosphere there. The grounds in AB are wooded making them at least appear to be more private. August will still be busy with kids still out of school so you'll need all the help you can get to get that quiet, romantic feeling at WDW. There are loads of "wooded" pathways to walk around at POR. POR and POFQ are, of course, connected by a (very long) walkway that runs down by the Sassagoula River. There are a few seats along the way to stop and take in the view. I'm not sure if they leave from POFQ but there are nightly carriage rides for rent ($35) leaving from the boatdock at POR that are very romantic. Also, renting a SeaRaycer and cruising down the Sassagoula is a relaxing way to spend time together, although the boat traffic may be a little heavier in August. (We did that in Dec.). As you can tell, I'm a big fan of POR. I think I have pictures from AB that I'll upload for you.

Magnolia Bend looking across the river from AB.

Bridge from AB to MB

Riverside Mill Food court at POR

Alligator Bayou
Sorry I don't have any pics of POFQ. The walkway that you see in the last pic of AB is the one that connects to POFQ. It's on the same side of the river where MB is on the other side across the bridge. HOpe I've helped in some way. Not meaning to discourage you from POFQ. It's neat and lively but for a romantic resort, I'd choose POR between the two. And people have their preferences between AB and MB. I like the rustic feel of AB where others like the more elegant feel of MB.