MsDisney,
I won't shoot!
But....I just want to make a few comments. First of all I totally agree that Universal needs a moderate on-site hotel. For what they offer now however there isnt a Disney property that can compare pricewise. Comparing deluxes to deluxes. I have stayed at most deluxes Disney offers at MUCH higher prices. You sure cant compare an All Star property to either of the Loews hotels. (I'm not saying you did, you didnt, I did) The room size alone is a major difference. Honestly I wont stay at a Disney moderate when I can book Hard Rock or Portofino for the same price.
I dont agree about the food at Universal being more expensive either. I found the prices at all the restaurants we ate at in City Walk to be very reasonable. The hotels breakfasts and character meals were even cheaper than those we had at Disney. Alcohol...I cant really compare. The kids meals everywhere we ate at Universal parks and the hotels were very cheap. Again I am comparing it back to back going from Disney to Universal. On top of them being cheaper to begin with (or the same) I was able to use coupons, AP, AAA for a discount.
I know Disney offers more parks but their tickets are never on sale. I have never seen buy one day get one free. They dont offer Entertainment discounts. AAA discounts for tickets are hardly ever available and when they do allow it its less than a 5% savings. Thats less than the membership.I havent heard any great praise about the Disney Club either. However...if you are a florida resident there are savings to be found! So yes in your case Disney probably is less expensive but not for me
Using your AP at Universal gets you:
20% savings at merchandise stores and carts
15% savings at all restaurants
Disney doesnt even offer a discount on any meals in the parks using an AP. Their AP doesnt apply for shopping either at any Disney Park or resort.
Bottom line for me...my trips to Universal have always been cheaper than a Disney trip.
Oh I also wanted to mention...The Loews program is something you would never find at an On Site Disney Hotel either...where in Disney could I accumulate 10 days and then have my room upgraded to a suite. (when available) I did take advantage of that last trip...It was amazing.
So you are very lucky Disney offers you those specials, but I dont get those same discounts and it sure adds up when comparing the two. Hope you didnt think this was shooting you...just wanted to give my opinion also