We had a great time also but with a few caveats. My wife did the two tank scuba dive. She enjoyed it, but felt rushed because the dive operators made a point to have everything done on time at
DCL's request. Apparently on the first Tortolla cruise, someone had double booked an afternoon excursion, which they missed. Not sure how they did that, but as a result the dives were a little short on time. She stilled enjoyed it tremendously and would definitely do it again.
DD, 7 and I did the Island Drive and Beach Break. This was just OK. The weather was overcast that day, so on the drive up there was not a lot to see, but we did get some nice pictures of the Magic. At the top there is a restaurant which has an observation deck. Again, not much to see. There was a small shop. The restaurant also charges a $1 per person to use the facilities. However, Cane Garden Beach is only about 15 minutes away where the restrooms are free. Cane Garden Beach was beautiful. They gave us a full hour there. We were given a free drink (rum punch, with or without rum), but other drinks were available for purchase for around $2 each. We were also given a chaise lounge each, but umbrellas were extra (They weren't needed because of the overcast). The Island Drive, Beach Break, and Lunch is the same excursion with a buffet lunch (chicken and ribs, with rice and vegetables) at the restaurant (Myett's ?).
Coming back from the beach was not so good. I had asked the driver how long it was back to the ship and he said about 15 minutes. I was worried about getting a snack for my daughter, but I figured with that short of a drive we'd be back no later than 1230. The actual drive took about an hour and was very, very boring. Even worse, the driver stopped to take pictures at some beach bar that was famous for having women's underwear tacked to the walls. Not really appropriate for a DCL excursion. We finally made it back to the ship after 1PM, with a very tired and hungry DD. I filled out a feedback form and the excursions desk responded very well. They promised to fix the return time and stop for the next cruise and paid for our getaway packages on
Castaway Cay as compensation. DCL makes every effort to make sure you have a good time, so I was very grateful. However, if I went back, I would just take a taxi to Cane Garden Bay on my own. There are lots of places to rent chairs and umbrellas and lots of restaurants (that are not decorated with underwear)
After feeding DD and meeting up with DW, we all left the ship (you are in port till 6 PM) to do some shopping. Quite frankly, there aren't a lot of shops in Roadtown. There is an open air market right outside the pier, but it consisted of about three dozen vendors all selling the same stuff either made in Mexico or China at a stiff markup (at least compared to Cozumel prices). There is another local market further on in Roadtown called Arts and Crafts Village (or something like that) which did have some items made locally, including a shop with crafts made by senior citizens. We bought DD a rag doll there, which she really liked. However, overall, there just isn't a lot in Roadtown. Our tablemates at dinner ate a the Pusser's in Roadtown and said it was quite good. They had booked a private sail to the Baths, which I think is the way to go. According to them, the boat anchors a short distance off shore and you swim/wade in. Then you sail back with snacks and drinks provided. We ran into them while shoppint at the Arts and Crafts Village.
Tortolla is beautiful and the other islands look gorgeous, but as I said before, if I went again, I would arrange a private excursion like Stacy (who heads up my entourage).