Tinker74 - I am guessing TigGem has booked her flights for Continental as B'ham - Newark - Orlando is one of their routes.
I have always found it cheapest to book Continental flights direct with Continental:
www.Continental.com
For that sort of price savings I would definitely go for that Jen, what a bargain for August!
We had always flown direct with Virgin / BA / charter in the past until our local airport started flying to Newark most days.
I don't like charter flights as I rarely want to, or are able to travel on the dates or number of nights they dictate to me.
For us, living down in the South West makes the journey to Gatwick long and adds additional costs as we have to stay in a hotel the night before. The journey home is very long and unpleasant when you are jetlagged and want to get home.
Now, we travel an hour to Bristol in our own car, and are through security much quicker than Gatwick. The same applies on the way back when we can be at home putting the kettle on two hours after the plane touches down. With Gatwick in the past we would have been lucky for that to have been under eight hours.
The flights are cheaper and more flexible than charters. I think the Continental staff are fabulous - we have done seven flights with them this year and they were excellent on all

of them.
Of course the snag is the longer travel time but it's nice when you get to MCO to not have to do customs and immigration.
We use the time at Newark to look round the shops, have a relaxing bite to eat and the last leg down to Orlando passes in a flash.
Taking all into consideration, I would err towards flying indirect if it meant avoiding the trek to Gatwick, even if it wasn't cheaper
Good advice above about leaving plenty of connection time!