We loved it and would do it again (also with capt ron, he's great fun). However, I wasn' impressed with the view. I have had much better views on land. I felt like we couldn't see all around the lake, it felt like our view was blocked somewhat from being so low. Not sure why I feel this way and everyone else thinks the view is so great!? We always get great places on land to view, maybe that's it? I think I prefer the more "straight on" view you can get from other places around the lake, not from the bridge area where the boats park.
Oh, and we had no smoke problems at all.
I would do it again though, no matter the cost--we love boats, and not having to fight the crowds for a spot is priceless. It's just the whole experience that we enjoyed--the relaxing tour of crescent lake first up to MGM and back, the food and drink we had on board, etc. You should definitely try it if you don't mind the cost, and you are lucky enough to get a boat. That's the worst part: I would do it every trip, but we can never book the boat! Anyone have one available for Oct 7-15th? LOL