If you had to eliminate one of these

[DreaminDisney]

Which one would you eliminate?

HDDR
Mama Melrose w/Fantasmic
California Grill
LTT night of MVMCP
Afternoon Tea -Garden View Lounge
Jiko
Coral Reef
Maya Grill (we're staying @ CSR)
Le Cellier
CRT (going to try and get this for Christmas morning)
1900 Park Fare (trying to get this for dinner on Christmas)

 

[cinmell]

Mama Melrose

 

[jcemom]

I wouldn't want to do both breakfast and dinner with Cinderella in the same day, so one of those two.

 

[MelanieC]

I'd probably get rid of the tea and keep the meals.

 

[disprincess86]

either one of the Cinderella meals or Maya Grill

 

[tluvstink]

If you can get CRT I would skip Park Faire.

Terri

 

[delauzons]

I would skip the tea. To me that is an extra-not a necessity. Your other places look great!

 

[MickeyNicki]

Mama Melrose, we did not like the food at all...it was served lukewarm and was super bland...all the parm cheese in the world could not bring flavor to the food. I ordered the eggplant napoleon and the bean ragu was raw!

 

[engle]

MAMA MELROSE!! We had BAD food and BAD service. NOT a good experience at all.

 

[MissMet]

Mama Melrose - TERRIBLE!!!!! (this coming from an Italian & her fam)

-bad food
-bad service
-OVERRATED
-YUCK!


You don't need the fantasmic seating, IMO. They save you seats way to the right side. The best seats, IMO, are in the center. We've even sat in the center section in the last row & it was perfect & a lot easier for getting out! Just get there early, like 30 minutes-tops, & you should be good. There really isn't a terrible seat in the house, though.

 

[slug]

HDDR - it's long and tedious and takes up a lot of time between traveling there and back and the 2 hr show.

 

[tinkandpan]

I would say HDDR or Mama Melrose. While the tea isn't a meal and is an extra- it is such a fun extra.

 

[dalt01]

shows ya how different we all are. when i looked at the post before i looked at any of the replys i said to myself. the two i would not get rid of would be HDDR and MM

 

[Leigha]

The tea then Mama Melrose. They just aren't as special as the others. Similar meals could happen in a lot of cities.

 

[GypsySue]

Maya Grill or Mama Melrose

 

[BeckyH]

Mama Melrose - never again! We even gave it a second chance after one bad experience - never again!

 

[amery]

Mama Melrose & California Grill.

The former for much of the same reasons already given and the latter only because it is a chain so if you had access to one close to home, I would opt for something that you can only do in WDW or the surrounding area and certainly anything experience-driven.

I got an ADR for CRT yesterday morning for 12/6 and if that experience lives up to it's billing, I will be one happy Disney camper

 

[dalt01]

california grill is a chain? news to me.

 

[lovindonald]

Mama Melrose

 

[Leigha]

Sorry I failed to see Maya Grill - I'd skip that first!! I stayed at CSR and don't see how it could be that different from the other restaurant there which is a CS but wonderful with steaks etc. I didn't know that California Grill was a chain but I do know it is the only CG with a view of MK!