Artist Pointe and Narcoosee's.
If you had asked me this question a few years ago, I would have chosen Yachtsman Steakhouse. It use to be our favorite. However, we went last summer and we felt the quality of the food wasn't as good. The service was spectacular as usual. Details: I ordered my steak medium rare. Well, it came to me medium well if not well. So, I sent it back and it came back medium rare on the inside, but the outside was charred quite a bit, it actually appeared to be cooked well if you were just going by how it looked. That affected the taste. I walked by the kitchen and the flame was way up there - I think they had it too hot. I don't know, I'm no expert. The prices are really high and I didn't think it was worth the $$. We had dined there in the past and loved the food. Top notch - aged beef. Delicious. I hope this was an isolated incident...but I don't know. I'm not in a hurry to go back. Very sad because this was our place. We even had a favorite waiter.
I despise Citricos. Had bad experiences there both times we've tried it. Bad service and just okay food. It's off my list for sure.
We love Brown Derby!!! Great food, atmosphere, desserts, and service.
Narcoosee's has great seafood selections, great service, excellent views. Oh, and they have a very nice steak as well.
Artist Pointe is one of my very favorites. Very unique menu. The salmon and hatfield pork chop are excellent. My favorite dessert, Artist Pointe Berry Cobbler, is served there. yummy. Plus, it's an excuse to visit the beautiful Wilderness Lodge. The service is usually wonderful, although once we had a very slow server. But, that happens sometimes.
Out of your choices, I think they are all good except Citricos. Although, lots of people love it. I'm thinking my experience at yachtsman steakhouse was isolated.
Have fun and enjoy whatever you choose.
PamNC
