Nice review and I always like hearing how much people can get done in reality. As a semi frequent visitor I think it’s tough to justify the cost but I can see the appeal for people with a short trip that don’t know the parks (and
lightning lane tricks) well.
To compare, here is what we accomplished with regular LLMP on Friday and Saturday this weekend. We are good at refreshing and found a majority of rides had immediate or almost immediate return times, and we ended up doing standby if under ~10 minutes to save our LLs (and ended up being too tired to repeat many rides anyways

). We had a couple MEPs that helped us out as well.
Friday (rope drop):
Alice
Snow White
Matterhorn (standby, waited 15)
Haunted mansion holiday
Runaway railway
Big thunder
Indiana jones
Pirates
Matterhorn
Space mountain
Buzz
Goofy’s sky school
Guardians
Monsters inc
Webslingers
Saturday (arrived just after park open):
Toad
Snow White
Pinnochio
Runaway railway (standby walk on)
Big thunder
Indy
Pirates
Smugglers run (standby, waited 10)
Rise (standby, waited 40)
Roger rabbit
Midway Mania
Webslingers
Monsters after dark
Space mountain
Haunted mansion
Cars (single rider, waited 25)
Overall seems like we did a similar number of rides but it probably took us several hours longer and required more steps (crossing the parks) using LLMP. Curious on your step counts? We had a 10-15 min walk coming from the Wyndham Garden Inn but overall around 28-29k these days for us. We were done by 9 or 10pm both nights, could have done more rides but too tired by then. We had a snack every 1-2 rides and hit just about every shop in both parks.
I forgot how long some of the lightning lanes can get since they merge so early such as Indy. Even those 15 minute waits add up especially on the feet! I think that’s a downside of the LLPP, even if you can ride everything, I’m not sure I’d have the endurance. And surely I’d rather re-ride a few select things than utilize LL for rides that don’t need a LL anyways. So many rides are walk on before 10AM after all.
If I had more money to burn I’d love to try and hit every single eligible ride on a LLPP, just to see how long it would take with the right strategy!