I am disappointed in my parents! Should I say something? UPDATE on page 2

Trish Bessette said:
The fact they are going to see her and spend the night is gift enough and your DN should see it that way too. I don't think they should be the ones obligated to bring her out on her birthday. Let the father do that, or her friends.


ITA. Why should Grandma and Grandpa be in charge of the birthday dinner - isn't that the parents job? It makes perfect sense to me to go a different day since there is apparently no birthday dinner planned and they would be expected to host one if they went.

It's really weird to me that anyone would EXPECT guests in their home to host dinner.
 
I think at 22 your DN is old enough to not be disappointed if people aren't able to be with her on her actual birthday. I think the fact that your parent's are making an effort to celebrate should be all that matters.
 
I would say it depends on if it's going to be no secret why they are doing what they are doing. If they can do this without the birthday girl realizing what's going on, then I agree that they should do what they like.

But if this is some kind of gesture to stick it to the dad, then why take the chance of ruining the girl's birthday?
 
disykat said:
ITA. Why should Grandma and Grandpa be in charge of the birthday dinner - isn't that the parents job? It makes perfect sense to me to go a different day since there is apparently no birthday dinner planned and they would be expected to host one if they went.

It's really weird to me that anyone would EXPECT guests in their home to host dinner.

DN is a senior in college - she lives in a house with a bunch of other girls. Her dad and brother live in a town about 20 miles away; my parents won't be in their home.
 
So they are basically not helping DN celebrate her birthday to avoid paying $14-20 for her dad and brother's food.
It sounds like they are helping her celebrate her birthday.

I would stay out of it, their relationship with her is between them.
 
missypie said:
DN is a senior in college - she lives in a house with a bunch of other girls. Her dad and brother live in a town about 20 miles away; my parents won't be in their home.

But they would still be the out of town guests - they shouldn't have to host a birthday dinner IMO. I think taking DN out to dinner another night makes perfect sense. Let her Dad and brother take care of the family celebration if there is one.

I can't even fathom this. When we have birthday celebrations, we invite the grandparents as guests - we don't expect them to come and pay for the party.

I also agree with another poster that DN may prefer spending her birthday with her friends. Going to dinner a different night with her grandparents is perfect.
 
missypie said:
My two daughters and my neice (DN) have birthdays within a week of each other. My parents are driving to see us, then driving three hours to spend one overnight with DN (turning 22), then coming back to my house. They will be with DN the day before her birthday, but are not staying for her birthday. The reason is that if they stay for her birthday, they will have to take not only DN out for dinner, but also her dad (my sister's ex) and his son from a later marriage. They get along fine with the ex; it's just that he never offers to pay for his or his son's food.

So they are basically not helping DN celebrate her birthday to avoid paying $14-20 for her dad and brother's food. That seems pretty petty to me. They could choose the restaurant and thus control the cost. I know that my sister's ex's cheapness has bugged them for years, but it seems like they should be able to rise above it.

I guess I won't say anything, but I dread if the topic comes up again. I'd hate to act like I support what they're doing. I feel like giving them a twenty and telling them I'LL pay for the food!


Not sure why dad and nephew would need to be included. Does she live with them and it would be awkward? Anyways, at 22, she should be able to understand if a celebration occurs around her birthday, rather than right on her birthday. Shouldn't be a big deal.
 
Missypie, it sounds fine to me.
Spending time privately with DN would be what I would prefer as well, regardless of the "dinner $$$" issue.

When there is ill will toward someone regarding divorce it is best to let sleeping dogs lie.
 
Well, there's always more to the story. Saturday my mom brought up that they didn't want to spend any time with my sister's ex...I was washing dishes, so I didn't have to really respond.

DN has an older brother who is a high school drop out who walked a lease and ran up a big cell phone bill...his dad co-signed both. Appareantly every time they're together, the ex brings up these bills and tries to get money out of them because his mother is their daughter. Geez, no wonder they don't want to be with him.

But, for no apparant reason, on Saturday afternoon they announced that they WOULD be staying for DN's birthday anyway.

Whatever. I'm just keeping my mouth shut!
 
missypie said:
Appareantly every time they're together, the ex brings up these bills and tries to get money out of them because his mother is their daughter. Geez, no wonder they don't want to be with him.

Always more to the story...which is why staying out of it works well...:thumbsup2 :lmao:
 
Any family drama I don't get drug into I stay out of. There's enough of it for me without piping up about stuff I don't have to.

Of course, your family is most likely not as nutso as mine. :)
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom