my engagement ring 11 years ago was around $500! We were young, didn't have a lot of money, we didn't want to spend years paying off my engagement ring, but I only wanted a small solitaire diamond anyway. For our 10th anniversary, my DH surprised me with the most gorgeous 3 diamond anniversary band in platinum. I know it cost over $5,000, but I don't have the guts to ask him just how much it was! I don't really want to know!

Honestly, I love my new ring, however, I was much more comfortable wearing my $500 ring!
All I can say is...don't spend more than you can afford! I have heard of people who put their girlfriend's engagement ring on credit, and then spend the next 10 years paying it off! And if she insists on something ridiculously expensive that she knows you can't really afford, I would really think things over!!!! I used to work with this girl, she was 21 years old, her BF 22, and they talked about getting married, and she said that if he showed up with a dinky little engagement ring, she'd say no! She wanted one that was $10,000! I felt really bad for her boyfriend!