Thank you for all of the responses, they were very helpful. I ended up booking with five day non-hopper tickets. We plan to utilize extra magic hours most mornings. Our first day will be like noon - 7pm (day 1), and our last day will be opening to maybe 11:30am (day 5). Then we will have three full days, with the hopes of using the pool in the late afternoon on one or two of those days. I think that should be enough time for our family. We don't shop, we move pretty quickly. Of the five days I am aiming to spend a total of 2 full days worth at DL broken up over three days, and about 1.5 days for DCA, leaving us a little time for swimming and a character meal. I can always add on the hoppers if we get there and decide we need them. But I'd rather use that money for a character meal and some souvenirs .