LOL I had to do the same thing this year. I just left them in the box they came in, or the bag if I got it from a store. Or shoved it in my stocking.
DH's presents are only wrapped in tissue paper. And one thing in his stocking is in the bubble wrap it came in. I figure that's two gifts - the pin I got him and the bubble wrap to pop.
Could you try closing your eyes and seeing how good you are at wrapping them blindly? Could become a new sport!
DH brought home a bag from the pin station at EpCot - gee wonder what it could be? - lol
The bag has been sitting on his dresser since we came home, the wrapping paper in sight in our den. Im really not sure if he'll wrap it or not.