Our first cruise was on the Disney Wonder--got us hooked on cruising

. DS8 was not so much into the characters but loved the kids club and all of the activites they did. The food was okay but Palo was awesome!!! I loved the shows but then again I am the Disney fanatic of the family.
Castaway Cay was just beautiful. I would do another
Disney cruise but now DS is older and taking him out of school is no longer an option--his choice, I respect that school is that important to him

. Cruising
DCL when he's out of school is just too expensive.
Our last cruise was on the Carnival Glory. We got an unbelievable price last summer after so many people bailed due to the swine flu and we had the Western itinerary that included Mexico. I have to say, we loved our Carnival cruise. We didn't have any expectations of the 'Disney experience' but found the staff to be very friendly and attentive and the ship clean and maintained. We met some wonderful families and had great tablemates. Food was better than DCL (except for Palo). I don't recall any of the drunks or whatever that Carnival seems to have a rep for (and I was looking

). There was a group of rowdy teens though

. The shows were for the most part pretty good--your usual cruise ship entertainment. DH enjoyed the casino. We had a nice sized balcony room too. Because we were able to get such a good deal on the cruise, we were able to go to WDW for 2 nights before and stayed at the Poly

. So I was able to get my Disney fix too. The biggest disappointment for DS was the kids club--they did alot of arts and craft stuff and more quiet activities that DS isn't really into--so he didn't spend alot of time there. Not a huge deal because there was alot of other things for him to do. He did enjoy the scavenger hunts, learning to dance hip hop, and time on the video games. This was hands down our best vacation ever. I would definitely cruise Carnival again if the itinerary was right (love their Eastern itinerary with Turks and Caicos, PR, St. Thomas, and Half Moon Cay).
We are booked on Oasis of the Seas for next April and are totally excited about that trip!!! While DCL is our first love, other cruiselines can offer IMO just as great an experience.