Honest comparison of Disney cruises VS the others (i.e. Carnaval, etc.)

I just did a 7 night on RCI Liberty of the Seas with my two young daughters. I did a comparison in my TR. I am currently reviewing a cruise on DCL in December so they are both fresh in my mind. We were surprised just HOW MUCH we loved the freedom class ships. Sooo, much to do. Such great ports and for a great price.:thumbsup2 We decided to switch our cruise plans for next Spring from DCL to RCI.

The comparison is on pg. 24. http://www.disboards.com/showthread.php?t=2357906
 
Does anyone know if water too cold (in your opinion) certain months at Castaway Cay? Any news on DVC member cruises for 2011?

We went for a January cruise and were able to swim. It does depend on where you are from though. We are from New England and it was warmer than summer ocean temps here.
 
Our first cruise was on the Disney Wonder--got us hooked on cruising :love:. DS8 was not so much into the characters but loved the kids club and all of the activites they did. The food was okay but Palo was awesome!!! I loved the shows but then again I am the Disney fanatic of the family. Castaway Cay was just beautiful. I would do another Disney cruise but now DS is older and taking him out of school is no longer an option--his choice, I respect that school is that important to him :thumbsup2. Cruising DCL when he's out of school is just too expensive.

Our last cruise was on the Carnival Glory. We got an unbelievable price last summer after so many people bailed due to the swine flu and we had the Western itinerary that included Mexico. I have to say, we loved our Carnival cruise. We didn't have any expectations of the 'Disney experience' but found the staff to be very friendly and attentive and the ship clean and maintained. We met some wonderful families and had great tablemates. Food was better than DCL (except for Palo). I don't recall any of the drunks or whatever that Carnival seems to have a rep for (and I was looking ;)). There was a group of rowdy teens though :mad:. The shows were for the most part pretty good--your usual cruise ship entertainment. DH enjoyed the casino. We had a nice sized balcony room too. Because we were able to get such a good deal on the cruise, we were able to go to WDW for 2 nights before and stayed at the Poly :lovestruc. So I was able to get my Disney fix too. The biggest disappointment for DS was the kids club--they did alot of arts and craft stuff and more quiet activities that DS isn't really into--so he didn't spend alot of time there. Not a huge deal because there was alot of other things for him to do. He did enjoy the scavenger hunts, learning to dance hip hop, and time on the video games. This was hands down our best vacation ever. I would definitely cruise Carnival again if the itinerary was right (love their Eastern itinerary with Turks and Caicos, PR, St. Thomas, and Half Moon Cay).

We are booked on Oasis of the Seas for next April and are totally excited about that trip!!! While DCL is our first love, other cruiselines can offer IMO just as great an experience.
 
Our first cruise was on the Disney Wonder--got us hooked on cruising :love:. DS8 was not so much into the characters but loved the kids club and all of the activites they did. The food was okay but Palo was awesome!!! I loved the shows but then again I am the Disney fanatic of the family. Castaway Cay was just beautiful. I would do another Disney cruise but now DS is older and taking him out of school is no longer an option--his choice, I respect that school is that important to him :thumbsup2. Cruising DCL when he's out of school is just too expensive.

Our last cruise was on the Carnival Glory. We got an unbelievable price last summer after so many people bailed due to the swine flu and we had the Western itinerary that included Mexico. I have to say, we loved our Carnival cruise. We didn't have any expectations of the 'Disney experience' but found the staff to be very friendly and attentive and the ship clean and maintained. We met some wonderful families and had great tablemates. Food was better than DCL (except for Palo). I don't recall any of the drunks or whatever that Carnival seems to have a rep for (and I was looking ;)). There was a group of rowdy teens though :mad:. The shows were for the most part pretty good--your usual cruise ship entertainment. DH enjoyed the casino. We had a nice sized balcony room too. Because we were able to get such a good deal on the cruise, we were able to go to WDW for 2 nights before and stayed at the Poly :lovestruc. So I was able to get my Disney fix too. The biggest disappointment for DS was the kids club--they did alot of arts and craft stuff and more quiet activities that DS isn't really into--so he didn't spend alot of time there. Not a huge deal because there was alot of other things for him to do. He did enjoy the scavenger hunts, learning to dance hip hop, and time on the video games. This was hands down our best vacation ever. I would definitely cruise Carnival again if the itinerary was right (love their Eastern itinerary with Turks and Caicos, PR, St. Thomas, and Half Moon Cay).

We are booked on Oasis of the Seas for next April and are totally excited about that trip!!! While DCL is our first love, other cruiselines can offer IMO just as great an experience.

Hey we did the Carnival Glory last summer as well did the Western at the end of July!:thumbsup2

Found there supper club to be fantastic!:love:
 
Hey we did the Carnival Glory last summer as well did the Western at the end of July!:thumbsup2

Found there supper club to be fantastic!:love:

I think we were on the same cruise--7/25 to 8/1 :)

We didn't end up trying the supper club---DS had dinner with us every night--the MDR food was really good.
 
I think we were on the same cruise--7/25 to 8/1 :)

We didn't end up trying the supper club---DS had dinner with us every night--the MDR food was really good.

Yes that was the cruise!:thumbsup2

We did WDW first DVC Beach Club & Saratoga Springs on points!

Had a great time! Did alot of shopping enjoyed Costa Maya went to the beach & it was not all built up!:worship:
We booked last minute got last 2 connecting staterooms (Ocean View) & an extra (3rd) for the teenagers! We were on deck 1!;)

Food was terrific in the main dining room, next time try the supper club it was first class 5 star white glove food & service!
 
We have sailed 6 times on Disney Cruise line and have loved every one of them. My husband and I love the Disney ships. Everything is great. We have been told to try other cruise lines for a comparison, so we went on a RCCL, Monarch of the Seas, in February. Had a terrible time, the ship was not clean, not kept up like the Disney ships; the food was awful/cold and the buffet line was a mess. The smoking was all over the ship, not just in their designated areas and no one did anything about it. So with that being said, we have 2 more cruises booked with Disney in the future. Can't wait!:love::yay::yay:
 
I was on the Monarch four times last year, Jan, Mar, July and Sept, 2009, and completely disagree with that statement. The smoking is not all over the ship because you can only smoke on one side of the ship and they have ashtrays on that side. I have seen security come up to my son, who smokes, and direct him to the other side of the ship. The only food I found cold were the salads and the foods that were supposed to be served cold. The food is much better than the DCL park food, and much better choices on the menu, that is offered at the regular dinners.

The buffet choices were great as the buffet was themed, with many different choices, on certain days aboard the 4 day cruise. Life the four days aboard the Monarch made me look differently at the DCL cruises. I cruised on both the DCL ships, three times in 2008, and found them to be lacking, in activities, compared to the Carnival, NCL and the RCCL ships.
 
We have sailed 6 times on Disney Cruise line and have loved every one of them. My husband and I love the Disney ships. Everything is great. We have been told to try other cruise lines for a comparison, so we went on a RCCL, Monarch of the Seas, in February. Had a terrible time, the ship was not clean, not kept up like the Disney ships; the food was awful/cold and the buffet line was a mess. The smoking was all over the ship, not just in their designated areas and no one did anything about it. So with that being said, we have 2 more cruises booked with Disney in the future. Can't wait!:love::yay::yay:

I totally agree with you on RCCL's food it is the pits:sad2::sad2: However both times we cruised with them the ships were very clean, that was the only good point to the cruise:rotfl2: Service was horrible :scared1::scared1::scared1: We will never do another RCCL cruise do to the service and food issues:sad1::sad1:

Rob
 
We have cruised RCCL 3 times and just booked Hawaii on the Rhapsody, we keep a close watch on the pricing and on our last 12 day cruise we got 6 price reductions in the last three months before sail date, we ended up paying just under $2,000 for the both of us. They won't call you so every few days I'd book a fake cruise to check the pricing.

DCL is our favorite for family cruises for the young grandkids, we are DVC so the money no longer bothers us as we use points and I can take nine of us for less than a $1,000 plus the $4,800 in maintenance. so for less than $6k we get a $21K cruise
 
We've only gone on one cruise ever ... on the Magic. So right now, we're trying to decide whether our next cruise will be a Princess or DCL one in the Medeterranean. The itinerary and price aside (slight differences), we're having trouble deciding which one to pick. My mom says she wants to sail on a different ship than one that we were just on. She thinks it will be boring being on the same ship.

So here's my question: Are the live shows in the Magic's theatre the same on a 7 day cruise in the Caribbean as they are on a 10 night Medeterranean cruise? (Doesn't that mean something repeats or there are dark nights in the theatre?) For example if we watched the Golden Mickeys in December in the Caribbean, are we destined to watch it again in the Medeterranean? If so, my mom has a point...and I'll lose (LOL) and we'll end up on Princess cause I can't counter that argument.

My family went on the Disney Med cruise. IMO the cruise ship was really a base or hotel for us. We were more off the ship than on. Most days we we left the ship by 7am & returned 7 or 8pm. We did see new shows on the Magic that I haven't seen since. (one reminded me of circus celuque) Disney also hired entertainers that were flown in just for our sea days.

Glad we chose Disney, there were many problems that happend on our cruise. I was amazed how Disney handled things and went up & beyond to solve any issuses. We felt safe being out of the USA with Disney to lean on. Just MOP
 

GET UP TO A $1000 SHIPBOARD CREDIT AND AN EXCLUSIVE GIFT!

If you make your Disney Cruise Line reservation with Dreams Unlimited Travel you’ll receive these incredible shipboard credits to spend on your cruise!





-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom