c3smom said:
We're just starting as homeschool parents, even though we've always talked about it even before our son(4yr) was born! Right now he thinks we "play" school even though he's learning.
Do or have any of you had any opposition from your family regarding your childrens education? It seems when ever my in-laws watch our son he starts talking about when he goes to school, when he rides a school bus, he'll be able to play with kids at school, etc. It drives us crazy!! My husband says he's talked to them but my tolerence is low when it comes to that. If they are not going to respect our decision, or keep thier opinions to themselves then I feel they shouldn't see him anymore!! But, that' sthe frustration talking.
Anyhow, we've joined up with a group of homeschoolers in our area and get together with them often. It's fun now, I'm afraid it'll get harder as he gets older.
We had mild opposition from the ILs. Let's just say I knew they thought I was nuts even though they never said anything. Now that DD is in 5th grade, I know again that they are getting worried about my sanity.

The whole middle school/highschool thing is getting to them. If we lived closer to my family I would imagine that a few of them would have said something. What we run into more though is random people we either don't know or barely know who ask questions like, "Don't you miss playing with other kids?" "Wouldn't it be fun to ride the school bus?" "Isn't it strange to not go to school when everyone else does?" I have gotten to the point now that I simply let my kids answer the questions. Their answers are basically, "We do play with our friends a lot" "My brother is my best friend and he is here all the time" "No, I hated riding the bus in Kindergarten. It's very loud." and "We love homeschooling. We don't have to be in school all day and then have homework too." or "Huh? Lots of kids homeschool."
My two younger ones--just 5 and 6.5--don't know anything different. To them this is just life and normal. DD is 10 and she did go to K but she loves homeschooling and I am pretty sure you couldn't pay her to go back. We did talk recently about going to middle school and she had a list of rational reasons why she wants to continue to homeschool. I have my own list so that worked out fine.
I have totally different advice than the PP. I think what your ILs are reacting to is the "differentness" of homeschooling. EVeryone just basically assumes their cute little grandkids are going to go off to Kindergarten and play and finger paint and yada yada. The thing is that #1 Kindergarten isn't like that anymore and #2 their grandchildren really can grow up to be normal, happy, functioning little people by not following the trend. It's just hard for them to see that right now. I would bet that their discussions with your DS are coming from a place of insecurity and worry of not being in the "norm" wiht all of their friends whose little GKs are going off to school. I would suggest that for now--as your DS is too little--you answer the questions. Cheerfully, concisely and then change the subject. I found it was useful to then throw in something about "Our co-op is doing the coolest field trip to this living history museum next week. Have you ever been there?" In a very cheerful inquisitive tone of voice. They usually have been where we are going and then I could ask them about it. That is if you are around. If you are not around, just confidently remind him that some kids ride the bus or what have you, but he is going to do school with mommy and meet with his friends in your group instead.
I do agree with the PP that you might need to cut back on the babysitting times if this is happening often. And I also think that it is excellent that you have already found a group and are gettting together with them. That will help both you and your son feel like you are not out of the norm and trust me it really will help with those folks who think you are crazy.
You know, it has just occurred to me. People feel free to comment on my not sending my children to school fairly often. I wonder what would happen if I started saying to people, "You send your kids to public school? Really? Don't you worry about the bad habits they will pick up, the liberal agenda in the schools and that they are wasting a heck of a lot of time standing in line and waiting for all the kids to do what the teacher says?"

What do you think guys? How would that go over?