Hollywood Brown Derby Fantasmic or Narcoosees

[starousse]

I have one open day with no tentative plans and was trying to figure out if I should go back an extra day at HS and do the Brown Derby Fantasmic package or spend the day at Downtown Disney and do Narcoosees at night. I do plan on going to Downtown Disney on my arrival night and maybe another night.
What do you think?

 

[Carrie in AZ]

We have always wanted to eat at Brown Derby and finally did so on our trip two weeks ago. We loved it!

 

[Pakey]

I think the food is better at Brown Derby if that's the only consideration.

 

[DansBride2009]

The Brown Derby is wonderful! We loved it so much we try to get in every time! And Fantasmic is amazing!

 

[DisneyFamily123]

I like the food at Brown Derby much better than Narcoosees. And the fantasmic show is very enjoyable. Seen fantasmic twice with the package, never without.... it was nice to not wait in the long lines I hear about. The fantasmic package is a set price and includes appetizers.... and if on the dining plan, still includes appetizers even if not on the deluxe plan.

My grouper dish and oyster and brie soup at Brown Derby was delicious. Read reviews of both restaurants (with pictures) at the 2010 review link below.

 

[juliebug1997]

If you're on DxDP, Narcoossee's is 2 credits. I don't know if Brown Derby is, but, if it is, at least you'd get the additional entertainment out of it.

 

[TDluvsDaisy]

We enjoy Brown Derby. It's really nice to use with the Fantasmic package. If you haven't done Fantasmic I highly recommend it.

That said, I love Narcoossee's. Food and service has always been good for us. Brown Derby is very slow.

 

[disneyfav4ever]

I would probably pick Brown Derby. The food is good at both restaurants, but with the added bonus of Fantasmic, Brown Derby gets the edge. Of course, if you time Narcoossees right, you can watch Wishes from there.