HELP!!!! Which ones would you choose???

[LBelle]

Hello! Hope you guys can help me out with making a decision on a few places.

A) Turf Club , Olivia's , Whispering Canyon OR Grand Floridian Cafe? (night 1)



B) Beaches & Cream , ESPN Club , Mama Melrose's OR Tutto Italia? (night 2)


I have to narrow these picks down so that I can make 2 dinner ADRs. It will be myself, DH and DS13. We have been to Whisp. Canyon and ESPN from this list previously.

Thanks so much for your help!!

 

[LBelle]

My 1st ever poll and no help.

Come on, guys!!!

 

[danielle782001]

Have fun with your first poll....

We went to the Turf Club for the first time a few weeks ago and truly LOVED IT! The atmosphere was really calm and nice, the food was excellent, and the service was terrific...This is one that we MUST do again.

I voted for all three sections but this is the one I wanted to comment on because I really think you will love the TC

 

[LBelle]

Thanks so much for your input! The Turf Club menu does interest us more than Olivia's.

So far, Grand Flor. Cafe is winning on the poll!!!! I wasn't expecting that but I'm happy about it! I was hoping to go there over the Whisp Canyon...I didn't mind it last time but it didn't thrill us either. Haven't been to GFC but it looks nice!

 

[JMD]

Maybe the lack of response is because your poll is a little confusing. You have four groups of restuarants to pick from, but you said you only need to 2 ADRs. Are your looking for one restaurant from A & B, and one from C & D, or just the best 2 restaurants?

Your March Madness style poll doesn't seem like the easiest way to ask your question.

 

[ROEDISNEY]

Not sure if this is what you want I picked 2 cause you said you needed 2.


Tutto Italia & Grand F Cafe

 

[LBelle]

Maybe the lack of response is because your poll is a little confusing. You have four groups of restuarants to pick from, but you said you only need to 2 ADRs. Are your looking for one restaurant from A & B, and one from C & D, or just the best 2 restaurants?

Your March Madness style poll doesn't seem like the easiest way to ask your question.

Now THAT made me laugh!!! Okay...so I re-read my first post and, yep, just a tad confusing! Thanks for letting me know. I've doctored it up now...is it easier to understand now?

Not sure if this is what you want I picked 2 cause you said you needed 2.


Tutto Italia & Grand F Cafe

That's perfect! Thanks so much for your help!

 

[KatMark]

For your first night, I'd go with Turf Club or Grand Floridian Cafe. I would not recommend WCC to my worse enemy--awful food and awful service.

I picked Mama Melrose for the second night; we've always had good food and great service here. I don't think you can make reservations at Beaches & Cream and we've never done the new Italian restaurant.

 

[JMD]

Now THAT made me laugh!!! Okay...so I re-read my first post and, yep, just a tad confusing! Thanks for letting me know. I've doctored it up now...is it easier to understand now?

Gotcha, thats for clearing that up.


For night one, I would pick Olivia's. I've eaten there several times and think it's one of the more underrated restuarants in WDW. That said, i wouldn't really go out of my way to eat any those 4. They all have their merits, so I would pick the one that best fits your schedule.

For night two, definitely Tutto Italia.

 

[Rosiekins]

WCC and Beaches and Cream!

 

[LBelle]

For your first night, I'd go with Turf Club or Grand Floridian Cafe. I would not recommend WCC to my worse enemy--awful food and awful service.

I picked Mama Melrose for the second night; we've always had good food and great service here. I don't think you can make reservations at Beaches & Cream and we've never done the new Italian restaurant.

Ya...I'm not too crazy about the WCC option. DH brought it up I think only because it's been about 5 years since we've been to that one. I'd prefer to go with GF that day. Beaches & Cream I know we can't make ADRs for...I was just looking for some options that have something different than most that I have booked in stone.

We will be doing, like every year: Le Cellier, O'Hana, and Wolf Pucks also I've got 50's PT and SciFi (L) again, Yak & Yeti, The Plaza (L) and Teppan Edo (1st time for those)

Was looking to go somewhere after a day at Typh Lagoon (Olivias OR Turf Club) OR to have TS on one of our MK days (WCC OR GFC)

Gotcha, thats for clearing that up.


For night one, I would pick Olivia's. I've eaten there several times and think it's one of the more underrated restuarants in WDW. That said, i wouldn't really go out of my way to eat any those 4. They all have their merits, so I would pick the one that best fits your schedule.

For night two, definitely Tutto Italia.

Tutto does seem to get fab reviews. That may have to be a definite!

WCC and Beaches and Cream!

Beaches & Cream REALLY interests our son, so might have to go with that one too!


Thanks so much everybody! I'm sure I'll figure out something. If there is anybody else who would like to leave input I'd be glad to hear them all!

 

[DVC_Princess]

Hi! I picked Turf Club for the first night - I think it's one of the hidden gems at WDW and we've always enjoyed our meals there (even eating there multiple times when staying at SSR). For night 2, they all have their merits. Beaches & Cream for dessert, ESPN has yummy bar-type food and we've always enjoyed lunch there (never had dinner though), but I picked Tutto Italia - we haven't eaten there yet since it changed over, but a bunch of the reviews sound really good and it's on my list of new places to try.

Have a great trip!!!

 

[kyirish25]

We just tried Tutto Italia a few weeks ago and LOVED it. The atmosphere, food and service were all top notch.

For the 2nd choice I went with Turf Club but don't have any personal experiences to give. But it is a place on my list of must try.

 

[janjandis]

Hey Lisa!! What night are you doing Le Cellier? We'll be there Fri at &:30.

 

[Pooh's-Honey-Pot]

Ohh would be Beaches and Cream for me - I've never had a bad bite there!