Help us decide

[java]

This year we are not seeing the huge benefit of staying onsite- plus $$$$.
So we started looking offsite
It’s narrowed down to 3 ranging in price from$1700-2500

$2500 is Bonnet Creek 3 bedroom- honestly thought that was the one then I read about all pools being like people soup and you can’t even get a chair.

$2000ish one Windsor Hills townhome
Very themed updated tiny pool no real good outside space but very nicely done. Game console in one of the kid rooms

$1700 again Windsor Hills(is it really only 6 miles to Disney?)
Stand alone home. Not as updated lightly themed. Good game room in the garage.
bigger pool in backyard with lounge chairs and 2 dining tables- and a grill.

and I’m still hoping for a dvc miracle like last year.

opinions?

oh edit to add cheapest would mean park hopping might be a possible add on(we are going to be with 3 older children 16 and up)
And it’s July

 

[Pooh's World]

This year we are not seeing the huge benefit of staying onsite- plus $$$$.
So we started looking offsite
It’s narrowed down to 3 ranging in price from$1700-2500

$2500 is Bonnet Creek 3 bedroom- honestly thought that was the one then I read about all pools being like people soup and you can’t even get a chair.



opinions?

Really just depends when you go I think.

I usually go off peak and the one time I was at Bonnet Creek very few people were in the pool.

 

[ENJDisneyFan]

We love Windsor Hills when staying offsite. Yes, it is very close to the parks and the resort is very nice with great amenities. You can't beat having your own private pool IMO (even if small). Between the 2 Windsor Hills, I'd probably go for the bigger pool if you plan to spend a lot of time in it.

 

[TamaraQT]

This year we are not seeing the huge benefit of staying onsite- plus $$$$.
So we started looking offsite
It’s narrowed down to 3 ranging in price from$1700-2500

$2500 is Bonnet Creek 3 bedroom- honestly thought that was the one then I read about all pools being like people soup and you can’t even get a chair.

A 3bedroom in Bonnet Creek for $2500??? I hope that is for more than a week!!!

 

[java]

I am confused on what the two of you are referring to as a confirmed reservation discount. Is this offer being sent to people that have reservations already or ones that you had but were cancelled? I had an original trip scheduled for June 28 - July 3. I ended up rescheduling it for November. I would love to get one of these bonus offers.

A 3bedroom in Bonnet Creek for $2500??? I hope that is for more than a week!!!

nope one week

 

[TamaraQT]

nope one week

One week for $2500???? What are your dates of stay? May I ask where you received your estimate/quote from?

 

[java]

Vrbo

 

[java]

We booked a Windsor hills house

 

[TamaraQT]

Vrbo

What are you dates? Have you looked on Redweek and/or TUG? Even eBay has reputable people to rent from. Is it too late for you to shop for a better rate? I think you still have time to get a better rate/quote.