Help!! Halloween vs Christmas?

[LEOW136]

Well here is the low down..
DH & I purchased an AP this year. i had never been to WDW for more than a day trip and DH has not been in years. We spent a lovely 2 week trip in January at BWV in a 1 Bedroom Villa, saw all the shows, parades, rides, parks. March we went for a long weekend and stayed at Pop for 4 nights. Enjoyed Flower & Garden Festival as well as relaxing by the pool, rides, and some amazing meals!
Now we had originally planed to make two more visits this year.
One in OCT and 1 in DEC. Thanks to the lovely price of airfare and living in Jersey(to far to drive) we can only make 1 more trip this year.
So my question is..
Would you rather go for Halloween/ F&W or Christmastime.
We looked at doing the week in Nov when they overlap but I am nervous it will be overwhelmingly busy.
We can take off for up to 7 days.
So have at it!!!
Someone please help me plan this trip!!!!

 

[saskdw]

WDW is so magical at Christmas I couldn't imagine going any other time. We have been there 3 of the last 4 Christmas and are currently considering again this year as long as Disney comes to the party with a FD offer.

 

[starousse]

Both times of year are my favorite, but there is just something extra magical about Christmastime in Disney.

 

[Qltrgrl2]

One thing to note....if you go at the end of Food and Wine (early November), you will be able to see some Christmas decorations and attend Mickey's Very Merry Christmas Party. This would be another time you may wish to consider for your last trip of the year.