My take: Hyatt is great for later arrivals, as often you have worked all day and then flown or you have a long travel time, or now it’s late and being done with travel at that time of night is all you want. Ours was the third reason.
Yes, it is a nice hotel and you can get an earlier PAT & BG if you use
DCL transfers.
But you do pay for all that. $$
I have only opted to stay in Cape Canaveral one time, at the Country Inn & Suites, to meet up with our fellow cruisers before a Transatlantic sailing that had lots of interaction here in the Boards. (Over a decade ago. Many more hotel options now).
If you opt for staying near the port, make sure you calculate transportation to dinner and back to hotel. Plus airport to hotel and hotel to port. If I am telling you something you already know, forgive me. I’d also check out the dining choices.
It is a chunk of time to occupy yourselves, but if you can get a hotel with a decent pool or enjoy the ocean or Ron Juan surf shop, it would be reassuring to be over the causeway in the morning. But I do love seeing the ship as I approach PC from the West on Boarding Day.
I’d probably rent a car and stay somewhere near WDW or SeaWorld, maybe Palm Parkway, wherever I could get a decent price for a hotel, maybe one with a big pool. Have dinner at a restaurant not in my hometown (it might just be Raising Cane’s or Fish & Chips in Disney Springs. Or go crazy with the Boathouse).
I like the independence of a car and would look for a one-way rental (often no drop-off fees between MCO & Cape Canaveral). They will shuttle you to the ship in the morning. I think that’s what we did the time we stayed by the port.
I think our biggest challenge is often what to do with ourselves if we arrive early afternoon. Pools and dinner are good time fillers.
I like the idea of staying at Disney and getting the free water park entry, but a 1:30 plane arrival and travel to WDW won’t leave you a lot of time before a water park closure at 5 pm. And it may be cool. Then just realized hotel pools may be cool, too.